Differences in the interaction of Escherichia coli RNase P RNA with tRNAs containing a short or a long extra arm

The phosphorothioate footprinting technique was applied to the investigation of phosphate moieties in tRNA substrates involved in interactions with M1 RNA, the catalytic subunit of Escherichia coli RNase P. In general agreement with previous data, all affected sites were localized in acceptor stem and T arm. But the analyzed examples for class I (Saccharomyces cerevisiae pre-tRNA(Phe) with short variable arm) and class II tRNAs (E. coli pre-tRNA(Tyr) with large variable arm) revealed substantial differences. In the complex with pre-tRNA(Phe), protection was observed at U55, C56, and G57, along the top of the T loop in the tertiary structure, whereas in pre-tRNA(Tyr), the protected positions were G57, A58, and A59, at the bottom of the T loop. These differences suggest that the size of the variable arm affects the spatial arrangement of the T arm, providing a possible explanation for the discrepancy in reports about the D arm requirement in truncated tRNA substrates for eukaryotic RNase P enzymes. Enhanced reactivities were found near the junction of acceptor and T stem (U6, 7, 8 in pre-tRNA(Phe) and G7, U63, U64 in pre-tRNA(Tyr)). This indicates a partial unfolding of the tRNA structure upon complex formation with RNase P RNA.