A wall-less vessel phantom for Doppler ultrasound studies

Doppler ultrasound flow measurement techniques are often validated using phantoms that simulate the vasculature, surrounding tissue and blood. Many researchers use rubber tubing to mimic blood vessels because of the realistic acoustic impedance, robust physical properties and wide range of available sizes. However, rubber tubing has a very high acoustic attenuation, which may introduce artefacts into the Doppler measurements. We describe the construction of a wall-less vessel phantom that eliminates the highly attenuating wall and reduces impedance mismatches between the vessel lumen and tissue mimic. An agar-based tissue mimic and a blood mimic are described and their acoustic attenuation coefficients and velocities are characterised. The high attenuation of the latex rubber tubing resulted in pronounced shadowing in B-mode images; however, an image of a wall-less vessel phantom did not show any shadowing. We show that the effects of the highly attenuating latex rubber vessels on Doppler amplitude spectra depend on the vessel diameter and ultrasound beam width. In this study, only small differences were observed in spectra obtained from 0.6 cm inside diameter thin-wall latex, thick-wall latex and wall-less vessel phantoms. However, a computer model predicted that the spectrum obtained from a 0.3-cm inside diameter latex-wall vessel would be significantly different than the spectrum obtained from a wall-less vessel phantom, thus resulting in an overestimation of the average fluid velocity. These results suggest that care must be taken to ensure that the Doppler measurements are not distorted by the highly attenuating wall material. In addition, the results show that a wall-less vessel phantom is preferable when measuring flow in small vessels.