Counteracting effects of thiocyanate and sucrose on chymotrypsinogen secondary structure and aggregation during...

Studies of numerous proteins with infrared spectroscopy have documented that unfolding is a general response of unprotected proteins to freeze-drying. Some proteins that are unfolded in the dried solid aggregate during rehydration, whereas others refold. It has been proposed for the latter case that aggregation is avoided because refolding kinetically outcompetes intermolecular interactions. In contrast, with proteins that normally aggregate after rehydration, minimizing unfolding during freeze-drying with stabilizer has been shown to be needed to favor the recovery of native protein molecules after rehydration. The purpose of the current study was to examine first the opposite situation, in which a denaturant is used to foster additional unfolding in the protein population during freeze-drying. If the protein is not intrinsically resistant to aggregation under the study conditions (e.g., because of intermolecular charge repulsion) and the denaturant does not disrupt intermolecular interactions during rehydration, this treatment should favor aggregation upon rehydration. With infrared spectroscopy we found that at concentrations of the denaturant Na thiocyanate (NaSCN) that only slightly perturbed chymotrypsinogen secondary structure in solution before freeze-drying, there was a large increase in protein unfolding in the dried solid and in protein aggregation measured after rehydration. Bands assigned to intermolecular beta sheet were present in the spectra of samples dried with NaSCN, indicating that aggregation could also arise in the dried solid. By examining the protein structure in the frozen state, we determined that in the absence of NaSCN the protein remains native. NaSCN caused structural perturbations during freezing, without the formation of intermolecular beta sheet, that were intermediate to structural changes noted after freeze-drying. In contrast, samples treated in the presence of NaSCN and sucrose had native-like spectra in the frozen and dried states, and much reduced aggregation after rehydration. These results indicate that during freezing and drying the sugar can counteract and mostly reverse the structural perturbations induced by NaSCN before and during these treatments.