Safe ischemia time in free-flap surgery: a clinical study of contact-surface cooling

Although the effectiveness of cooling in extending tolerable ischemia time is well-established experimentally, most free-flap surgeons are still concerned about this problem and try to limit the ischemic period to less than 1 hr. Clinically, contact-surface cooling has been used empirically to prolong the limits of ischemia time; however, its applications are unproven. It also remains unknown whether contact-surface cooling has detrimental effects on flap tissue, such as vessel spasm leading to thrombosis. The purpose of this study was to determine, in a clinical setting, if skin, muscle, and bone free flaps of considerable size could tolerate prolonged cold ischemia without adverse effects. Flap size, cold ischemia time, and surgical outcomes were studied in 189 consecutive free flaps. Microvascular thrombosis occurred in 5/378 (1.3 percent) of anastomoses. The overall flap complication/flap loss rate was 7/189 (3.7 percent). Mean ischemia time for all flaps was 2 hr and 6 min (range: 30 min to 5 hr, with one case at 6 hr and 8 min). The mean ischemia time for cases with flap complications was 2 hr 20 min, while ischemia time for cases with thrombosis averaged 2 hr 13 min. The one flap loss had an ischemia time of 1 hr 35 min. No statistically significant correlations existed between duration of ischemia time or duration of contact-surface cooling and the incidence of thrombosis, flap complication, or flap failure. Among the conclusions were that, within a 4-hr period of cold ischemia, the application of the surface-cooling technique is not detrimental to free flap surgery; thus, concern for ischemia, and especially the "no reflow" phenomenon, generally should not interfere with efficient and orderly free-flap surgery.