Related Experiment Videos
Monitoring and evaluating managed care for children with chronic illnesses and disabilities
P W Newacheck1, R E Stein, D K Walker
1Institute for Health Policy Studies, University of California, San Francisco 94109, USA.
Insights
Managed care for children with chronic illnesses requires careful monitoring and evaluation. A new strategy is proposed to assess impacts on access, quality, and family well-being.
Area of Science:
- Pediatric Healthcare Research
- Health Services Research
- Managed Care Policy
Background:
- Managed care arrangements are increasingly prevalent for children with chronic illnesses and disabilities.
- The consequences of this shift for vulnerable pediatric populations remain largely unknown.
- Understanding these effects is crucial as managed care becomes the dominant healthcare model.
Purpose of the Study:
- To outline a novel strategy for gathering essential data on the impact of managed care on children with chronic health conditions.
- To inform necessary adjustments in managed care models for improved pediatric outcomes.
Main Methods:
- A comprehensive literature review was conducted on managed care's effects on children with chronic conditions.
- Key domains for monitoring and evaluating managed care were identified.
Main Results:
- Two primary research approaches are recommended: monitoring and evaluation.
- Monitoring involves tracking enrollment, access, satisfaction, and general outcomes over time.
- Evaluation employs experimental or quasi-experimental designs to compare outcomes (access, utilization, quality, satisfaction, cost, health, family impact) pre- and post-enrollment or against fee-for-service models.
Conclusions:
- Assessing managed care outcomes for children with chronic conditions is challenging.
- The proposed monitoring and evaluation strategies offer a structured approach.
- Significant investment from government, foundations, and health plans is essential for implementing these strategies and ensuring positive outcomes for children.
Objective:
Children with chronic illnesses and disabilities are increasingly enrolling in managed care arrangements. Yet, the rapid expansion of managed care has unknown consequences for children with chronic conditions and disabilities. As managed care is likely to become the predominant mode of medical practice for children with chronic health problems, information gained from a thorough assessment of existing managed care models could be helpful in indicating adjustments and modifications that could result in improved outcomes for this population. the purpose of this article is to outline a new strategy for collecting needed information on the effects of managed care on children with chronic health problems.
Methods:
We reviewed the literature on the effects of managed care on children with chronic conditions and disabilities. We identified key domains relevant to monitoring and evaluating managed care for this population.
Results:
Two research approaches can provide helpful information for assessing the effects of managed care on children with chronic conditions. First, a monitoring strategy could be pursued in which enrollment trends in managed care, enrollee perceptions of access and satisfaction with care, and other general indicators of outcomes would be tracked over time using inexpensive and rapid turnaround data sources. Second, an evaluative strategy could be pursued using experimental or quasiexperimental designs, in which outcomes across a variety of domains for children with chronic conditions in managed care are compared with: (a) outcomes for the same children before enrollment in managed care; or (b) outcomes for similar children remaining in traditional fee-for-service settings. Evaluation and monitoring strategies should focus on outcomes in a number of domains including: (1) access to care; (2) utilization of services; (3) quality of care; (4) satisfaction with care; (5) expenditures for care; (6) health outcomes; and (7) family impact.
Conclusion:
Assessing outcomes that result from enrollment in managed care for children with chronic health problems presents a formidable challenge. The research strategy outlined in this article presents one approach to meeting that challenge. The monitoring and evaluation strategies described here would require commitment of additional resources on the part of government, private foundations, and/or health plans. Given the paucity of existing information and the stakes for children with chronic conditions and their families, investment of added resources in a comprehensive monitoring and evaluation strategy is essential.