Benign biliary strictures: a review of 21 years of experience

The treatment of patients with benign biliary strictures remains a challenge for even the most skilled biliary surgeons. Within the wide range of causes of benign biliary strictures, iatrogenic lesions represent one of the major ones. Biliary reconstruction with Roux-en-Y anastomosis remains the treatment of choice for most cases of benign biliary strictures despite recent reports about endoscopic or percutaneous management that have been quite encouraging.

We retrospectively evaluated 194 patients who underwent surgery for benign biliary strictures over a 21-year period. The biliary strictures were classified into eight different types according to their level. The surgical procedures had been tailored mainly to the site and the extent of the structure as well as the overall status of the patient.

Postoperative mortality and morbidity rates were 2.6 percent and 20.1 percent, respectively. The results we obtained were 79.6 percent good, 8.9 percent moderate, and 11.5 percent unsatisfactory. The mean follow-up was 9.3 years. In particular, hepati-cojejunostomy performed in low- and mid-level strictures had the best prognosis (good, 85.5 percent), while high and diffuse strictures had worse results (good, 70 percent), although with only hepaticojejunostomy according to Hepp-Couinaud, this percentage increases to 81 percent.

Correct preoperative assessment of the site and extent of the biliary stricture is important in the choice of the gold-standard surgical procedure. Hepaticojejunostomy and hepaticojejunostomy according to Hepp-Couinaud are the treatments of choice in most instances of benign biliary strictures. Cholangiojejunostomy and hepatic resections are rarely indicated and are performed mostly for highly complicated and intrahepatic strictures. Endoscopic or percutaneous balloon dilation should be reserved for high-risk patients.