Modeling of halorhodopsin and rhodopsin based on bacteriorhodopsin

Bacteriorhodopsin (BR), halorhodopsin (HR), and rhodopsin (Rh) all belong to the class of seven-helix membrane proteins. For BR, a structural model at atomic resolution is available; for HR, diffraction data are available only down to a resolution of 6 A in the membrane plane, and for Rh, down to 9 A. BR and HR are closely related proteins with a sequence homology of 34%, while Rh does not share any sequence homology with BR. An atomic model for HR is derived that is based on sequence alignment and the atomic model for BR and is improved by molecular dynamics simulations. The model structure obtained accounts well for the experimentally observed difference between HR and BR in the projection map, where HR exhibits a higher density in the region between helices D and E. The reason for this difference lies partially in the different side chains and partially in slightly different helix tilts. The scattering amplitudes and phases of the model structure are calculated and agree with the experimental data down to a resolution of about 8 A. If the helix positions are adopted from the projection map for HR and used as input in the model, this number improves to 7 A. Analogously, an atomic model for Rh is derived based on the atomic model for BR and subjected to molecular dynamics simulations. Optimal agreement with the experimental projection map for Rh is obtained when the entire model structure is rotated slightly about two axes in the membrane plane. The agreement with the experimental projection map is not as satisfactory as for HR, but the results indicate that even for a nonhomologous, but structurally related, protein such as Rh, an acceptable model structure can be derived from the structure of BR.