Prediction of teratogenic potency of valproate analogues using cerebellar aggregation cultures

The aim of this study was to develop a novel in vitro system suitable for preclinical testing for developmental toxicity of drugs. An assay system consisting of primary cultures of dissociated cerebella from 6-day-old mice was chosen, since it allowed quantification of neuronal aggregation and fasciculated neurites. A human teratogen, the antiepileptic drug valproic acid (VPA), as well as its structural analogues, ( +/- )-4-en-VPA and E-2-en-VPA, with varying teratogenic activities, were tested and found to affect aggregation and fiber formation of cerebellar neurons. Based on a dose-response study, the concentrations of compounds causing 50%, inhibition (IC50) of formation of thick and thin fibers were determined. The lowest IC50 values were found for VPA (52 +/- 7 and 86 +/- 11 microM for thick and thin fibers, respectively), which in vivo caused the highest rate of exencephaly among the three compounds tested, ( +/- )-4-en-VPA exhibited intermediate values (150 +/- 30 and 300 +/- 40 microM), whereas the highest IC50 values were found for E-2-en-VPA (260 +/- 42 and 430 +/- 40 microM). The latter compound does not induce neural tube defects, but has been shown to have neurobehavioral effects in prenatally exposed animals. Subsequently, the purified S- and R-enantiomers of 4-yn-VPA (teratogenic and non-teratogenic, respectively) were tested for their effects on aggregation and fiber formation of the cerebellar neurons. Treatment with S-4-yn-VPA resulted in pronounced changes in numbers of aggregates and fasciculated processes compared to the cultures treated with R-4-yn-VPA, indicating that the intrinsic stereoselective potency of the enantiomers may be correlated to the difference in their effects on cerebellar neurons in vitro. Thus, the teratogenic potency of VPA and its analogues correlated with their effects on aggregation of neural cells and formation of fasciculated neurites in primary cultures of dissociated cerebella, indicating that the in vitro assay system employed may be used as a pre-screening test for prediction of teratogenic potency of drugs.