A recently silenced, duplicate PgiC locus in Clarkia

Previous electrophoretic analysis showed that 17 diploid species of the wildflower Clarkia (Onagraceae) have two cytosolic isozymes of phosphoglucose isomerase (PGIC; EC 5.3.1.9), whereas 15 other diploid species have a single PGIC. Molecular studies revealed that the two isozymes in the former species are encoded by duplicate genes, PgiC1 and PgiC2, whereas the single isozyme in the latter is always encoded by PgiC1. Phylogenetic analysis of the nucleotide sequences implied that PgiC2 was silenced four times independently in the genus. Here we describe a psi PgiC2 from C. mildrediae, a species in which only PgiC1 is expressed. The discovery of the psi PgiC2 is significant because it confirms a formal prediction of the phylogenetic analysis. The psi PgiC2 includes 5,039 nucleotides corresponding to 18 of the 23 exons of PgiC, as well as the intervening introns and 3' nontranslated region. The absence of an increase of nucleotide substitutions in its "exons" suggests that the gene was silenced recently. The present study appears to be the first to establish that a specific duplicate gene locus regularly expressed in a group of related plant species has been silenced in one of them. The multiple independent silencings of PgiC2 suggest that it remained functional but inessential in ancestral lineages. We discuss the possibility that PgiC2 may have been preserved in these lineages by selection against mutants causing defective PGIC1-PGIC2 heterodimers.