Mechanical valve in aortic position is a valid option in children and adolescents

The choice of a valve substitute remains a challenge in young patients, with numerous reports of early degeneration and calcification of biological valves in this age group. Therefore an assessment of the long-term results after mechanical aortic valve replacement in children was initiated.

A retrospective study was conducted in 54 consecutive patients aged 1.1 to 17 years (mean 12.8 +/- 4 years) operated on between 1975 and 1993. Aetiology was congenital in 34 patients, rheumatic in 13, infectious in 5, and dystrophic in 2. Concomitant surgery included mitral valve replacement (10), aortic annulus enlargement (9), correction of truncus arteriosus (7), Bentall operation (2), coarctation repair (2), tricuspid valvuloplasty (2), correction of double outlet right ventricle (1), and replacement of a right ventricle to pulmonary artery conduit (1). A Bjork-Shiley valve was implanted in 14 patients, and a St Jude Medical valve in 40. All patients were given Warfarin with a monthly INR control. Follow-up was completed through questionnaires mailed to referring physicians and direct clinical examination.

Overall early mortality was 13% (7 cases), and 6% (2 cases) in the 32 patients operated on after 1984. Follow-up was complete in 45 survivors (2 lost to follow-up), with a total follow-up of 261 patient-years. There were 6 late deaths, 4 being cardiac and due to persistent LV dysfunction, and 2 valve-related, due respectively to major gastro-intestinal bleeding and massive thromboembolism. Linearized rates of valve thrombosis and anticoagulant-related hemorrhage were both 0.3% per patient-year. Actuarial survival rate was respectively 84.5% at 5 years and 70.2% at 10 years. Reoperation was necessary in 3 patients for recurrent LV outflow tract obstruction. One patient with severe LV dysfunction is awaiting a heart transplant.

We conclude that the longterm outcome after mechanical aortic valve replacement in children and adolescents is satisfactory and comparable to currently available reports on biological substitutes. The mandatory anticoagulant therapy is well tolerated in this age group.