Hepatitis C virus replicative levels and efficiency of genotyping by specific PCR and antibody assay

We studied factors which influence the detection of hepatitis C virus genotypes by the group-specific PCR of the sequence within the core region gene and by the newly developed genotype-specific NS4 antibody assay. Genotyping was performed on 75 hepatitis C virus carriers in Japan, where patients with hepatitis C viremia are exclusively infected with genotype 1b, 2a, and 2b. PCR failed to identify genotypes in 8 (11%) patients, whereas 12 (16%) patients, including the 8 patients mentioned above, could not be genotyped by the serological assay. Serological genotypes showed almost complete agreement with those found by the PCR except that double infection was revealed in only two of the eight patients serologically judged to be coinfected with genotypes 1 and 2. In each assay, disease activity and levels of viremia assessed by a competitive reverse transcription PCR assay were significantly lower in patients infected with untypeable isolates than in those infected with typeable ones (P < 0.01). The PCR could identify the genotypes of isolates from all 64 patients with levels of viremia of > or = 10(6) copies/ml, and the genotype-specific antibody responses were found in 60 (94%) patients. In contrast, isolates from only 3 (27%) of 11 patients with low levels of viremia (< 10(6) copies/ml) could be genotyped by the PCR (P < 0.00001), and these patients showed the genotype-specific antibody responses (P < 0.00001). These findings suggest that low levels of hepatitis C virus replication may reduce the efficiency of genotyping by serological assay as well as by PCR.