Validation of retroviral detection for rodent cell-derived products and gene therapy applications

The availability of sensitive assays for detecting infectious murine retroviruses has become critical for the development and acceptance of a number of biopharmaceuticals, including monoclonal antibody-derived products and gene therapy vectors. Comparative studies demonstrated that the PG4 S+L- retrovirus infectivity test routinely yields higher titres than the mink cell test for xenotropic, amphotrophic and MCF murine retroviruses. A validation study for the PG4 S+L- assay demonstrated very good linearity (r2 of 0.95 to 0.99), reproducibility within a study (+/-0.35 log10 units), and precision between tests (+/-0.45 log10 units). Interference (or selectivity) in the presence of a non-specific antibody was insignificant (less than 0.2 log10 units). Sensitivity levels established from measurements as virus titres approach zero demonstrated a threshold value of 2-3 focus forming units (FFU)/ml. Two methods for increasing assay sensitivity were used including: (i) increased product samplings combined with a Poisson distribution analysis, and (ii) a 14-day co-cultivation with Mus dunni cells. Each of these methods was shown to increase sensitivity by at least one log10 unit. Murine retroviruses may also be detected by a less sensitive immunofluorescence assay (IFA) using specific monoclonal antibodies; this assay is essential for detecting certain recombinant ecotropic MuLVs. In summary, murine retroviral detection ranked by sensitivity is mink S+L- < IFA with monoclonal antibodies < PG4 S+L- < Mus dunni co-cultivation followed by PG4 S+L-.