"Adaptive" behavior of ligand-gated ion channels: constraints by thermodynamics

The calcium-induced calcium release channel of the cardiac sarcoplasmic reticulum has been reported to inactivate in a novel manner (termed "adaptation"), which permits reactivation by exposure to successively higher concentrations of calcium. I examined the limitations placed by thermodynamics on the possible kinetic mechanisms for such behavior. The mechanism suggested by Gyorke and Fill, in which the affinity of a calcium-binding site decreases during adaptation, is not thermodynamically feasible for a passive system, but requires an external input of free energy. Possible sources of such energy are 1) metabolic energy, which is excluded by the fact that adaptation was observed in isolated channels in the absence of ATP, or 2) coupling of ion permeation to gating, for which there is currently no evidence. I derived a general limit on the thermodynamic feasibility of a sequence of channel activations and adaptations, irrespective of channel kinetics, from the requirement that the free energy must decrease during the spontaneous evolution of the system from the state existing immediately after a step increase in [Ca2+] to the state of maximum open probability that follows. The opening of the channel must involve an increase in free energy, which must be compensated by the free energy released by the incremental binding of calcium. This requirement leads to a complicated system of inequalities, which was simplified and manipulated algebraically into the form of a linear programming problem. Numerical solution of this problem showed that the sequence of adaptations of the SR channel observed by Gyorke and Fill requires the presence of at least 10 calcium-binding sites on the channel if it is to occur in the absence of exogenous sources of free energy. This indicates either that a large number of calcium-binding sites participate in the regulation of the SR calcium release channel, or that the existing data are significantly flawed with respect to the low open probability in the resting state, the importance of "calcium spike" artifacts from flash photolysis, or both.