Effectiveness of the thyroid scan in evaluation of the solitary thyroid nodule

Solitary, palpable thyroid nodules are common, but only a small percentage are malignant. It is important to evaluate these nodules in a cost-efficient manner that avoids missing a cancer. Historically, radioisotope imaging has played a major role in the workup of thyroid nodules; however, with the advent of fine needle aspiration biopsy (FNAB), this role has become less clear. From 1974 to 1994, 770 patients with a solitary nodule underwent thyroidectomy. Preoperatively, 471 had thyroid scans, and 149 had FNAB. The incidence of carcinoma in nodules excised on the basis of thyroid scan was 23 per cent, whereas the incidence of carcinoma was 37 per cent when FNAB was used (P = 0.003). Fine needle aspiration was a significantly better predictor of malignancy than thyroid scan and resulted in a smaller proportion of excisions for benign nodules. Thyroid scan provided little additional information in those patients who underwent FNAB. Because thyroid scans add little in determining which nodules require surgical excision, they should no longer be a routine part of the evaluation of a solitary thyroid nodule.