Accuracy of mammographic appearances after breast fine-needle aspiration

The objective of this study was to document the observation that fine-needle aspiration of palpable breast masses by use of a modified technique performed shortly before mammography need not adversely interfere with mammographic interpretation nor produce falsely suspicious mammographic lesions that delay meaningful evaluation and management in this breast clinic.

In a retrospective record review 1007 women who were seen in the Breast Diagnostic Center at Women's and Children's Hospital from January 1992 until April 1995 and who had fine-needle aspiration of a palpable solid breast mass within 2 weeks before mammography were analyzed overall and in 10-year age group subsets. The mammographic reports of "suspicious" lesions were correlated with having had a prior fine-needle aspiration (within 2 weeks).

Of the 1007 women undergoing fine-needle aspirations, 91 had a cytologic or tissue biopsy specimen diagnosis of malignancy. Of these, 72 had "suspicious" mammograms and 19 had "nonsuspicious" mammograms. The calculated positive predictive value was 58%. The negative predictive value was 98%. Mammographic sensitivity was 79%. Specificity was 94%. Age stratification did not reveal any meaningful trends. Of the 916 patients with benign cytologic results of fine-needle aspiration specimens, 52 had "suspicious" mammograms and 864 had "nonsuspicious" mammograms.

For patient convenience and expeditious diagnosis of a palpable breast mass, fine-needle aspiration can be performed on the initial visit and mammograms subsequently taken within 2 weeks without undue clinical confusion or misleading mammographic findings. Concordance of the diagnostic triad consisting of (1) clinical impression (by history and examination), (2) fine-needle aspiration, and (3) mammography gives a reliable conclusion and can appropriately be used as the basis for clinical management of a breast mass. However, when there is doubt or anxiety about the diagnosis either on the part of the patient or the physician, a definitive histologic tissue diagnosis should obtained.