Determinants of heart rate variability during deep breathing: basic findings and clinical applications

The measurement of heart rate variation during forced breathing (HRDB) is a well-known clinical test of parasympathetic function. It is known that normal values of HRDB are strongly dependent on age. However, little is known about other physiological factors that may lead to reduced HRDB values that may mimic parasympathetic failure. Thirty-two normal subjects (age 56.7 +/- 12.4 years) and 32 neurological patients with pathological autonomic test findings (age 57.9 +/- 10.2) were studied. Oscillations in heart rate and in mean arterial blood pressure were recorded in the supine position during forced breathing (6 cycles/min) using the Finapres monitor. Amplitudes of heart rate and blood pressure waves at 6 cycles/min (HR6 and ABP6) as well as gain values (Gain6 = HR6/ABP6) and phase differences (delta phi 6) between HR and ABP waves were calculated by means of spectral analysis. The mean (+/-SD) HR6 in normal subjects was 6.34 +/- 3.36 cycles/min with a mean ABP6 of 5.11 +/- 2.49 mmHg. HR6 correlated significantly with age (r = -0.426) and with ABP6 (r = 0.602). No significant correlation was found between HR6 and mean blood pressure, mean heart rate or sex. From 24 patients with pathological findings in the classical HRDB value, only nine could be classified as pathological when the effect of ABP6 was considered. In conclusion, ABP variations significantly influence the amplitude of heart rate variations during forced breathing. We interpret these findings in terms of a baroreflex mechanism of HRDB including both vagal and sympathetic efferents. Normal reference value tables for clinical HRDB studies should not only consider age but also the amplitude of blood pressure variations.