Mechanical implications of humero-ulnar incongruity--finite element analysis and experiment

Previous studies show that the humero-ulnar joint is physiologically incongruous [Eckstein et al. (1995a) Anat. Rec. 243, 318-326] and exhibits a bicentric (ventro-dorsal) distribution of subchondral mineralization [Eckstein et al. (1995b) J. Orthop. Res. 13, 286-278]. We therefore asked: (1) Does humero-ulnar incongruity bring about a bicentric distribution of contact pressure? (2) Do tensile stresses occur in the subchondral bone of the trochlear notch that are in the same order of magnitude as the compressive stresses? (3) Do ventral and dorsal maxima of subchondral bone density correlate with a bicentric distribution of strain energy density? To that end, a two-dimensional finite element model was designed. The shape and material properties of the bones were based on CT and the boundary conditions selected to agree with resisted elbow extension at 90 degrees of flexion. The incongruity and contact areas were determined experimentally from casts, and the pressure distribution with Fuji Prescale film. In the model and the experiment contact stresses above 2 MPa were recorded in the ventral and dorsal parts of the joint, and values below 0.5 MPa in the depth of the notch. In the model, tensile stresses of 2.9 MPa were observed in the subchondral bone of the ulna, but not in the humerus. The subchondral strain energy density yielded a bicentric pattern in a model with homogeneous subchondral bone properties. It is shown that humero-ulnar incongruity brings about a bicentric distribution of contact pressure, a tensile stress in the notch that is in the same order of magnitude as the compressive stress, and a distribution of strain energy density that correlates with subchondral density patterns.