Antibacterial effects of amalgams on mutans streptococci in an in vitro biofilm test procedure

Conflicting data continue to be presented in the literature regarding the antibacterial potential of various amalgam alloy compositions. The aim of the present study was to compare the antibacterial effects of 4 different amalgam samples on mutans streptococci using two in vitro test procedures. Glass and bovine enamel served as negative controls. The first test, one commonly used, consisted of immersing freshly prepared disks of the six materials in culture broth inoculated with mutans streptococci. Optical density measurements of the broth served to evaluate bacterial growth. This was followed by a biofilm technique which provided more intimate contact between the bacteria and specimen surfaces. With the exception of one high-copper lathe-cut amalgam, the first test revealed no antibacterial potential of the samples whereas the second test with the biofilm design elucidated significant differences in antibacterial potential between the amalgam alloy compositions and the controls. The biofilm technique, used in an in vitro test procedure, reflects the conditions of the oral environment more accurately than conventional test designs.