Multiple sclerosis: comparison of the human T-cell response to S100 beta and myelin basic protein reveals parallels...

The adoptive transfer of autoreactive S100 beta-specific T cells induces experimental autoimmune panencephalomyelitis and uveoretinitis in the Lewis rat, mimicking the distribution of lesions seen in a subset of patients with multiple sclerosis. We studied the frequency and functional properties of the human T-cell response to S100 beta in eight patients (two relapsing-remitting multiple sclerosis, one chronic-progressive multiple sclerosis, two with multiple sclerosis and uveitis, two neuromyelitis optica, one panuveitis) and in seven healthy individuals, using bovine S100 beta for T-cell stimulation. Both in patients and controls, the frequency of S100 beta-specific T-cell responses was half of that obtained for myelin basic protein (MBP), and only 10% of that obtained using purified protein derivative (PPD). The stimulation indices obtained in response to S100 beta were also less than half those obtained with either MBP or PPD. However, four long-term S100 beta-specific T-cell lines were established and studied in more detail. The four T-cell lines all exhibited a CD4+, CD8-, T-cell receptor alpha beta + surface phenotype and secreted tumour necrosis factor-alpha, interferon-gamma, interleukin-10 and interleukin-4 upon antigenic stimulation, but they were heterogenous with respect to T-cell receptor usage; two T-cell lines expressed V beta 2, one V beta 6.7 and one V beta 13. Antigen-specificity was confirmed using bovine S100 beta beta and alpha beta-isoforms, as well as a recombinant rat S100 beta preparation. The response to S100 beta was shown to the HLA-(human leukocyte antigen-) DR-restricted for two of the S100 beta-specific T-cell lines. Human S100 beta-specific T-cell lines were cytotoxic, although to a lesser extent than MBP-specific T-cell lines derived from the same donors. The phenotypic and functional properties of human S100 beta-specific T-cell lines raise the possibility that these T cells are pathogenic, as they are in the rat. The low frequency and proliferative index of S100 beta-specific, as opposed to MBP-specific T-cell responses suggests that the T-cell response to this widely expressed calcium-binding protein is under more efficient regulatory control.