Active site analysis of P450 enzymes: comparative magnetic circular dichroism spectroscopy

Recent structural studies indicate that the substrate- and O2-binding distal pocket of the P450 enzymes are not identical. Thus, P450terp (CYP108) from the alpha-terpineol-metabolizing Pseudomonad differs from P450cam (CYP-101) (C. A. Hasemann et al., J. Mol. Biol. 236, 1169, 1994). In contrast, the distal pockets of P450terp and P450BMP (CYP102 heme domain; Bacillus megaterium) are more closely similar, including novel hydrogen-bonding interactions between the distal H2O ligand and the I helix (C. A. Hasemann et al., Structure, 3, 41-62, 1995). To evaluate the significance of these differences, we have compared solution magnetic circular dichroism (MCD) spectra of P450terp with spectra of other P450 enzymes (e.g., P450cam, P450BMP, P450BM-3holo, and P450BM1), as well as with spectra of chloroperoxidase and NO synthase. Spectra of native P450terp are more similar to those of P450BMP and those of mammalian P450LM-2 than to those of P450cam. Upon substrate-binding, the MCD spectra of ferric P450terp and all other thiolate-ligated heme systems examined to date display a strong Soret band that is distinctly unique relative to the typical Soret MCD pattern(s) of catalases or other 5-coordinate ferric heme systems. This intense negative MCD feature thus appears diagnostic for cysteinate-linked ferric hemes. In the case of ferrous P450s, the intensity of the Soret-region MCD trough varies between substrate-bound and substrate-free enzymes (despite the fact that the substrate is NOT in direct contact with the heme moiety). A novel finding of particular interest is the clear spectral shifts of the Soret MCD band between the substrate-bound and substrate-free forms of ferrous-CO-P450terp. No such observation has been made previously. Furthermore, the band positions for BOTH types of P450terp are red-shifted from known bands of ferrous-CO-P50cam. These data thus indicate a surprising sensitivity of MCD spectra to active-site polarity and to H2O occupancy, concurring with reports of distal pocket effects on CO-binding rates and equilibrium constants. Comparative analysis of the spectral properties of P450terp with MCD spectra of other P450 enzymes, as well as with chloroperoxidase and NO synthase, demonstrates both the expected similarities and the significant differences that reflect active-site structural features. The detailed spectral analysis of P450terp relative to other P450 enzymes presented herein includes the first observation of a substrate-induced spectral shift for a ferrous-CO-P450. Furthermore, testable structural predictions for P450-BM-1 and for the novel NO synthase enzyme (neither of which has been crystallized to date) are made herein. This work thus provides insights into structurally defined P450s and may also lead to understanding of other P450 enzymes.