Differential effects of DNA supercoiling on radical-mediated DNA strand breaks

Supercoiling is an important feature of DNA physiology in vivo. Given the possibility that the reaction of genotoxic molecules with DNA is affected by the alterations in DNA structure and dynamics that accompany superhelical tension, we have investigated the effect of torsional tension on DNA damage produced by five oxidizing agents: gamma-radiation, peroxynitrite, Fe2+/ EDTA/H2O2, Fe2+/H2O2, and Cu2+/H2O2. With positively supercoiled plasmid DNA prepared by a recently developed technique, we compared the quantity of strand breaks produced by the five agents in negatively and positively supercoiled pUC19. It was observed that strand breaks produced by gamma-radiation, peroxynitrite, and Fe2+/EDTA/H2O2 were insensitive to DNA superhelical tension. These results are consistent with a model in which chemicals that generate highly reactive intermediates (e.g., hydroxyl radical), but do not interact directly with DNA, will be relatively insensitive to the changes in DNA structure and dynamics caused by superhelical tension. In the case of Fe2+ and Cu2+, metals that bind to DNA, only Cu2+/H2O2 proved to be sensitive to DNA superhelical tension. Strand breaks produced by Cu2+/H2O2 in the positively supercoiled substrate occurred at lower Cu concentrations than in negatively supercoiled DNA. Furthermore, a sigmoidal Cu2+/H2O2 damage response was observed in the negatively supercoiled substrate but not in positively supercoiled DNA. The results with Cu2+ suggest that the redox activity, DNA binding orientation, or DNA binding affinity of Cu1+ or Cu2+ is sensitive to superhelical tension, while the results with the other oxidizing agents warrant further investigation into the role of supercoiling in base damage.