The cytokine and histological response in islet xenograft rejection is dependent upon species combination

Islet xenografts have clinical potential, may avoid hyperacute rejection, and therefore are a good place to examine the cellular xenograft immune response. The aim of this study was to examine the cellular, humoral, and cytokine response in islet xenograft rejection and to determine the difference in the immune response with a different donor species.

Two islet xenograft models (DA rat islets to B6AF1 mouse and canine islets to B6AF1 mouse) and a mouse syngeneic control model were examined histologically and by a semiquantitative polymerase chain reaction method.

There was significant up-regulation of all intragraft cytokines tested (interleukin [IL]-2, IL-4, IL-5, IL-10, and interferon-gamma) in both xenograft models compared with the controls. However, the dog islet grafts had higher levels of IL-4 and IL-5 gene expression than the rat islet grafts, which, conversely, had higher levels of interferon-gamma gene expression. These differences correlated with the histological and anti-donor antibody production differences between the two models. The dog to mouse model had an intense eosinophilic infiltrate and an early up-regulation of anti-donor antibody, whereas there was little eosinophilic infiltrate and a delayed anti-donor antibody up-regulation in the rat to mouse model.

The mouse used different mechanisms to reject the rat and canine islets, suggesting that the immune response in islet xenograft rejection may be dependent on the species combination. It may not be possible to characterize the cellular xenograft rejection response in a bipolar manner as has been the case with humoral rejection response. Caution therefore needs to be taken before extrapolating the cellular immune responses seen in animal models to the clinical setting.