Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction and joint dynamics during stair climbing

Athletes with anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) deficiencies exert decreased knee extension moments during level walking (quadriceps avoidance gait), and yet within a few months of ACL reconstruction they are often expected to return to competitive sport. To investigate this issue further, 10 normal subjects and seven ACL deficient patients were evaluated both pre- and post-operatively (mean follow-up of 6 months), and each performed multiple trials ascending a staircase which consisted of three steps. Bilateral joint angles, moments, powers, and work were measured and the data were ensemble averaged and statistically analyzed (repeated measures ANOVA with significance level set at 0.05). Anterior-posterior knee laxity decreased significantly (from 7.9 mm to 5.8 mm) while subjective knee function also improved following ACL reconstruction (knee score increased from 70.4 to 88.5). Pre-operatively, there were no statistically significant differences in biomechanical parameters between the patients' ACL-deficient and intact sides and the normal subjects. Post-operatively, however, statistically significant reductions were seen for the peak moment (91.9 vs 22.5 Nm), power (181 vs 84 W), and work performed (28.0 vs -5.6 J) at the injured knee, which was also the knee from which the patellar tendon graft had been harvested. These reductions were accommodated by significant increases in excursion, moment, and power at the contralateral ankle joint. The results indicate that while the ACL reconstruction were successful in restoring anterior-posterior knee stability, the decrease in knee power and work performed post-operatively by the injured (i.e., donor) knee suggests that donor site morbidity may need to be critically evaluated over a long-term period.