Reproductive potential: its influence on the susceptibility of a species to pesticides

Acute lethal concentration estimates (72-hr LC50) and population growth rates (7-day instantaneous rate of increase) of two mite species, an herbivore, the two-spotted spider mite Tetranychus urticae Koch, and the generalist predator mite Iphiseius degenerans Berlese, were developed after exposure to two pesticides, dicofol and Neemix. For each pesticide, LC50 estimates for both species were similar, yet the two species exhibited completely different susceptibility when population growth rate was the endpoint evaluated; I. degenerans was much more susceptible than T. urticae to either pesticide. For example, populations of I. degenerans became extinct after exposure to 250-ppm azadirachtin, the active ingredient in Neemix, while T. urticae populations became extinct after exposure to 1000 ppm. A similar relationship was found for dicofol. The no observable effect concentration (NOEC) for population growth rates after Neemix exposure was 4 ppm for I. degenerans and 125 ppm for T. urticae. These NOEC values were equivalent to the acute LC2 for the immature stage of I. degenerans and the acute LC65 for the immature stage of T. urticae. Consequently, populations of T. urticae were able to compensate for high losses of individuals while I. degenerans populations could not compensate for losses. An analysis of reproduction data indicated that unexposed T. urticae produced four to five times more offspring than I. degenerans. This in itself was important because it indicated that I. degenerans was intrinsically more susceptible than T. urticae because similar effects on reproduction would be more devastating to the species with a lower reproductive rate. Results indicate that a species' reproductive potential can greatly influence its susceptibility to toxicants.