Related Experiment Videos
[Heart transplantation--state of the art today]
B M Meiser1, W von Scheidt, M Weis
1Herzchirurgische Klinik, Klinikum Grosshadern der Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München.
Insights
Heart transplantation is a last resort for end-stage heart failure, but donor shortage is critical. New donor criteria and improved immunosuppression, like tacrolimus, offer hope for more patients.
Area of Science:
- Cardiology
- Transplantation Medicine
- Immunology
Background:
- End-stage congestive heart failure significantly reduces quality of life and life expectancy.
- Heart transplantation is the ultimate therapeutic option, with a 1-year survival rate of 84%.
- A critical shortage of donor organs necessitates careful patient and donor selection criteria.
Purpose of the Study:
- To review current criteria for heart transplant candidate selection.
- To discuss expanded donor criteria and management strategies.
- To evaluate the impact of cardioplegic solutions and novel immunosuppressive agents on long-term graft survival.
Main Methods:
- Analysis of patient selection criteria based on ejection fraction, cardiac index, filling pressures, and functional parameters.
- Review of broadened donor criteria, including age limits and pre-transplant evaluation.
- Examination of donor management protocols and cardioplegic solutions.
- Comparison of traditional immunosuppressive regimens with newer agents like tacrolimus (FK506).
Main Results:
- Tight patient selection criteria include low ejection fraction (<25%), low cardiac index (<2.0 L/min/m2), high filling pressures (>20 mm Hg), and large end-diastolic diameter (>80 mm).
- Functional parameters like maximal oxygen uptake (<10 mL/kg/min) also indicate transplant need.
- Elevated pulmonary vascular resistance (>4-5 Wood units) can be a contraindication for orthotopic transplantation.
- Expanded donor criteria include acceptance of donors up to 60 years old, requiring thorough evaluation.
- Cardioplegic solutions, particularly high potassium concentrations, may influence graft vessel disease.
- Tacrolimus (FK506) shows promise as a potent immunosuppressant, with early studies indicating better rejection-free rates compared to cyclosporine.
Conclusions:
- Despite advances, donor organ scarcity remains a major challenge in heart transplantation.
- Optimized patient and donor selection, meticulous donor management, and judicious use of cardioplegic solutions are crucial for successful outcomes.
- Novel immunosuppressive agents like tacrolimus represent a significant advancement in preventing graft rejection and improving long-term graft survival.
Abstract:
In spite of pharmacological progress, end stage congestive heart failure is still associated with a decrease in quality and expectation of life. Heart transplantation remains the last therapeutic option for these patients. While the one year survival rate has increased over the last few years up to 84%, a major problem remains the significant lack of donors. Therefore, the criteria for the selection of candidates for cardiac transplantation have to be kept quite tight: Evidence of poor outcome without transplantation is associated with ejection fractions below 20 to 25%, cardiac indices less than 2.01/min/m2, left ventricular filling pressure above 20 mm Hg and a enddiastolic diameter of > 80 mm. There are, however, also quite important functional parameters indicating the need for heart transplantation, e.g. the maximal oxygene uptake being less than 10 ml/kg/min or below 50% of the age-appropriate value. Elevated pulmonary vascular resistance above 4 to 5 Wood units without a significant decrease during application of prostaglandin derivatives or inhalation of NO represents a contraindication for orthotopic heart transplantation; alternatively, a heterotopic transplantation can be considered. Since there is a significant shortage of suitable donor organs, the donor criteria have been broadened, e. g. the accepted donor age was increased to 60 years. Based on these extended criteria, a careful donor evaluation including cardiac history, cardiac examination, ECG and echocardiogram has to be performed. Coronary angiography in older donors is suggested, but in many cases not possible due to circumstances. Further precondition for a good graft function is a sophisticated donor management until the time of explantation. Hypovolemia and hypocalemia, hypothermia, hypoxia and rapid lost of circulating triiodothyronine (T3) have to be detected and balanced. The cardioplegic solution used might not only have an impact on the immediate postoperative performance of the graft, but also on the long term outcome, particularly with regard to graft vessel disease. There are generally two types of solutions: Those with intracellular and those with extracellular electrolyte concentrations. In addition, the potassium concentration might be of some importance. Potassium seems to damage endothelial cells and trigger subsequent immunological reactions. Therefore, high potassium concentrations in the cardioplegic solution might correlate with the incidence of graft vessel disease during the long term follow-up. The surgical technique for orthotopic heart transplantation developed at the beginning of the sixties by Lower and Shumway has been used unchanged for the last 30 years. The only alteration recently introduced is the separate direct anastomosis of the pulmonary and systemic veins in order to improve the atrial function. Until recently the commonly employed immunosuppressive strategy after heart transplantation consisted of the standard drugs cyclosporin, azathioprin and prednisolon. Some transplant-units use additionally induction therapy with antibody preparations. Many centers, however, abolished this regimen due to significant short and long term side effects. Promising new, more specific antibodies (which are chimerized or humanised) could revive the induction concept. The most thoroughly tested novel immunosuppressive agent is tacrolimus (FK506). It has been demonstrated to be 10 to 100 times more potent than cyclosporin A in in vitro and in vivo models. It binds to a different binding protein (FK-binding-protein) than cyclosporin (cyclophilin), but has a similar mechanism of action inhibiting the expression of T-cell-activator genes for certain cytokines. First non-randomised studies after heart transplantation performed at the University of Pittsburgh revealed that significantly more tacrolimus than cyclosporin patients were free of rejection. In order to confirm these observations, we performed a prospective randomised controlled clin