In vitro and in vivo interaction between cisplatin and topotecan in ovarian carcinoma systems

Topotecan, a camptothecin analogue, is a specific inhibitor of topoisomerase I approved for use in the treatment of patients with refractory ovarian carcinoma. The drug's mechanism of action suggests a potential efficacy of drug combinations incorporating DNA-damaging agents. In an attempt better to define a rational basis for drug combination we examined the effect of topotecan on the cytotoxicity and antitumor activity of cisplatin in an ovarian carcinoma system growing in vitro and in vivo as a tumor xenograft. The in vitro cell system included a cisplatin-sensitive cell line, IGROV-1, and a cisplatin-resistant subline, IGROV-1/Pt0.5, which is characterized by p53 mutation and loss of normal function of the wild-type gene of the parental cell line. This cell system was chosen since the cell sensitivity to DNA-damaging agents appears to be dependent on p53 gene status. Cytotoxicity was assessed by the growth inhibition assay using different schedules: (a) a 1-h period of cisplatin exposure followed by a 24-h topotecan treatment and (b) a 1-h period of simultaneous exposure to cisplatin and topotecan. In the case of the sequential schedule, an additive interaction was observed in IGROV-1 and IGROV-1/Pt0.5 cells. When the simultaneous schedule was used, a synergistic interaction, more evident for the cisplatin-sensitive cells, was found. On the basis of these observations at a cellular level, the effect of concomitant administration of the two drugs (i.e., the most favorable schedule) was studied in the IGROV-1 tumor xenograft, which is moderately responsive to cisplatin and topotecan. Suboptimal doses of each drug (with a low dose of topotecan, 5.1 mg/kg) achieved an antitumor effect comparable with or superior to that of the optimal dose of a single treatment (tumor weight inhibition, 60%), thus indicating a pharmacological advantage of the combination over the single treatment. However, an increase in the topotecan dose (7.1 mg/kg) was associated with an evident increase in the toxicity of the combination, thereby suggesting that the drug interaction was not tumor-specific. Although the molecular basis of the drug interaction is not clear, it is likely that inhibition of topoisomerase I affects the ability of cells to repair cisplatin adducts. Such findings may have pharmacological implications since they suggest the potential clinical interest of topoisomerase I inhibitors in combination with cisplatin.