Quantification of dynamic velopharyngeal port excursion following sphincter pharyngoplasty

The sphincter pharyngoplasty is a surgical procedure designed to correct velopharyngeal dysfunction. Its advocates cite the theoretical advantage of its induction of dynamic activity of the neovelopharyngeal port, but this dynamic activity has yet to be quantitatively demonstrated in the literature. The purpose of this study was to quantify postoperative velopharyngeal dynamism and to document the results of intervention outcome on sphincteric excursion measurements from minimal-to-maximal orifice closure. We conducted a 7-year retrospective review of speech videofluoroscopy evaluations in patients who had undergone sphincter pharyngoplasty in our center. Between 1989 and 1994, there were 58 patients so treated for postpalatoplasty velopharyngeal dysfunction by two surgeons using the same operative technique. Patients for whom sphincter pharyngoplasty was recommended fulfilled both of the following criteria: (1) velopharyngeal dysfunction caused by an anatomic, myoneural, or combined deficiency of the velopharyngeal sphincter that would not be expected to be managed by speech therapy alone, and (2) preoperative videonasendoscopy and speech videofluoroscopic studies that demonstrated large-gap coronal, circular, or bow-tie closure patterns or velopharyngeal hypodynamism. Of the original 58 patients, 24 underwent postoperative speech videofluoroscopic evaluations with basal views. Of these, 20 of the evaluations (83 percent) were of adequate quality to be included in a research study. Still images showing maximum and minimum excursion of the sphincter in basal view were obtained. To test for observer reliability, the speech videofluoroscopic studies were randomized and presented for measurement to the same individual on two occasions, each session separated by a 1-month time interval. Topographic imaging software was used to obtain maximum and minimum measurements to within 0.1 mm. Partitioning the variance of the data showed that measurement variability was a very small portion of the total, and that difference between the minimum and maximum values was the largest source of variability. Of the total variability in the data, 64.0 percent originated in the minimum/maximum difference, 34.3 percent came from patient variability, and only 1.7 percent resulted from original or repeat measurements. The patient variability may be exaggerated because of variability in the scale of measurement. Results of this study indicate a quantifiable and statistically significant difference in maximum-to-minimum excursion of sphincteric closure. Sphincter pharyngoplasty appears to be dynamic in the majority of cases.