Analysis of treatment results of hypopharyngeal cancer

Sixty-three patients with squamous cell carcinoma of the hypopharynx were treated at the University of Tokyo between 1985 and 1993. Twelve patients were treated with surgery alone, 16 with preoperative irradiation, 26 with postoperative irradiation, and nine with irradiation alone. A tumor dose of 50 Gy (25 fractions/5 weeks) was used in postoperative irradiation, 40-60 Gy in preoperative irradiation, and 70 Gy in irradiation alone. When "number of indications," including, for example, partial pharyngectomy, positive or close (< or = 5 mm) margin, and extracapsular extension, was used for multivariate analysis in patients who underwent surgery, it proved to be the only significant prognostic factor for gross survival. Six of seven patients with a positive surgical margin or close margin who received postoperative irradiation had local recurrence. A tumor dose of 50 Gy (25 fractions/5 weeks) in postoperative irradiation is not enough. It is difficult to cure by irradiation metastases to the parapharyngeal lymph nodes large enough to be detected with CT. It is necessary to irradiate parapharyngeal lymph nodes prophylactically, but 50 Gy in postoperative irradiation may not be enough from our results. The same may be true for metastases to the paratracheal nodes, which lie close to the lower poles of the thyroid gland or within the superior mediastinum and are difficult to access through surgery. In the patients who were operated on, N stage and the number of lymph node metastases were significant for gross survival. When "number of indications" was used for analysis, "number of indications" proved to be the most significant prognostic factor for gross survival.