[Cytogenetic study of thyroid patients treated with external irradiation or radioiodine]

Where clinically permitted, either external irradiation or radioiodine therapy is usually recommended for the treatment of differentiated thyroid cancer patients. This paper describes an attempt to clarify the radiation burden and the distribution of radiation doses on the lymphocytes in consequence of these two therapeutic modalities, and the circumstances of the applicability of biological dosimetry. Thyrotoxic patients with intact thyroid glands underwent 131I therapy were also analysed for this purpose. An analysis was made of the extent to which exposure to local neck irradiation (50 Gy) or radioiodine therapy (1734-2600 MBq) causes chromosomal aberrations in the lymphocytes of thyroid disease patients after total or subtotal thyroidectomy, or thyrotoxic patients with intact thyroid glands (185-595 MBq). The irradiated volume of lymphatic tissues played the most important role in the formation of chromosomal aberrations. External irradiation caused 10-times more aberrant cells than 131I therapy did in cancer patients. In thyrotoxic patients the lower therapy doses of radioiodine caused a significantly higher frequency of aberrations than that observed in thyroid cancer patients. Selective radiosensitivity of lymphocytes was supported by the analysis of the Poisson distribution of aberrations, which suggested a homogeneous dose distribution only in 131I-treated and thyroidectomized cancer patients. In conclusion, we suggest that the results of studies of the genetic alterations in the lymphocytes exposed to radioiodine, under well-defined circumstances should not be ignored before the mode of radiation treatment is chosen. On the other hand, in the modelling of accidental environmental radioiodine exposure, only thyrotoxic patients with an intact thyroid gland and heterogeneous dose-distribution are a suitable group.