Breathhold MR urography: comparison between HASTE and RARE in healthy volunteers

The purpose of our study was to determine relative values of rapid acquisition relaxation enhancement (RARE) and half-Fourier acquisition single-shot turbo spin-echo (HASTE) sequences in breathhold magnetic resonance (MR) urography in healthy volunteers under nonobstructive conditions of the urinary tract. A total of 20 healthy volunteers underwent MR urography with breathhold RARE and HASTE sequences at 1.5 T. For evaluation, the urinary tract was divided into nine segments on each side. Visualization of segments and artifacts was scored and the intensity ratios (InR) were determined. The upper five urinary segments were sufficiently visualized with RARE and significantly better with HASTE (renal calices, p = 0.002-0.037). The middle and lower ureter was sufficiently delineated both with RARE and HASTE, but HASTE images were statistically superior (p = 0.009-0.041). Both in RARE and HASTE images, the lower ureter was frequently superimposed by bowel contents and bowel motion. Superimposition of genital organs degraded image quality in eight of ten female volunteers. InRs were superior with HASTE in the kidney and ureter (p = 0.0003-0.0125). RARE InRs were higher in the bladder (p = 0.0008-0.014). We concluded that neither the RARE nor the HASTE sequences allowed the evaluation of the entire urinary tract under nonobstructive conditions. Although it cannot entirely replace intravenous urography, MR urography seems to lend itself to combination with other MR techniques, particularly in the investigation of pelvic or retroperitoneal disease.