Pathology review of screening negative neuroblastomas: a report from the Quebec Neuroblastoma Screening Project

The Quebec Neuroblastoma Screening (QNS) Project completed a 5-year program for measuring urinary vanillylmandelic acid (VMA)/homovanillic acid (HVA) levels at age 3 weeks and/or 6 months in 89% of 476,603 Quebec-born infants from 1989-1994; 45 screening positive preclinical cases (S-positive cases) and 20 congenital/neonatal (C/N) cases were identified. As of April 1997, an additional 59 cases in the same birth cohort were diagnosed clinically; these neuroblastomas developed after screening verified normal VMA/HVA levels (S-negative cases).

Pathology specimens from 45 of 59 S-negative cases were reviewed centrally and classified according to the Shimada system. Results were compared with clinical data and also with S-positive and C/N cases.

Of 45 S-negative cases, 27 tumors had favorable histology (FH) and 18 had unfavorable histology (UH). Approximately 52% of FH tumors were diagnosed before age 1 year, whereas UH tumors were nearly exclusively (94%) diagnosed after age 1 year (P < 0.01). Approximately 89% of FH tumors were Stage I, II, or IV-S, whereas 72% UH tumors were Stage III or IV (P < 0.001). All children with FH tumors were alive at last follow-up (range of follow-up period: 9-79 months; median, 35 months), whereas 8 children with UH tumors died of disease even after limited follow-up (range of follow-up period: 0-60 months; median, 20 months). By contrast, S-positive and C/N cases were predominantly (97%) FH tumors, often (76%) Stage I, II, or IV-S, with excellent clinical outcome (survival rate of 98%).

The majority of the UH neuroblastomas that developed in the birth cohort of the QNS Project were included in the group of S-negative cases and could not be detected by the screening at age 3 weeks and/or 6 months.