Issues of non-compliance in mental health

This paper explores and questions the ideas and notions in respect of non-compliant behaviours. Traditionally, research into this area has focused on identifying individual characteristics from within the adult branch of nursing and within the confines of the medical model of compliance. Little research has investigated the phenomena of non-compliance within the specialty of mental health. It may be suggested that identifying characteristics in this setting is futile. There are many factors determining a client's compliance behaviours. These include gender, social class, race and socio-economic status. Those suffering from mental ill health are often the most vulnerable in society and it may be argued that as such are often coerced into accepting treatment with those who refuse frequently being labelled as non-conformist. The ability of the client to refuse treatment should be based upon informed consent, but is often dependent upon the social prejudice of the health care professional, their misuse of power to bring about compliance behaviours and their inability to act as an effective advocate. Finally, by eliciting information, shared negotiation, planning and improved communication health professionals may improve compliance behaviours based upon the client's needs and wishes.