Actual and perceived postural sway during balance specific and non-specific proprioceptive stimulation

A group of patients with balance complaints (n = 16) was compared with a group of normal subjects (n = 17) by means of posturography, subjective assessments of balance, anxiety and unsteadiness when standing on a force platform with eyes closed. Postural instability was induced by vibratory stimulation of the calf muscles (20, 40, 60, 80 and 100 Hz). As a control condition, the arm (biceps) was stimulated at similar frequencies. In order to control for arousal, blood pressure and heart beat were assessed. Furthermore, questionnaire responses on psychological measures were collected. Results showed clear differences between the groups in terms of imbalance and self-reports. However, the 2 groups displayed similar increases of imbalance during calf stimulation and no increase during arm stimulation. Patients generally rated less increase of unsteadiness when the calf was stimulated than did the controls. No differences in arousal were found between the groups or within conditions. Results are discussed in terms of the proposed desynchrony between symptoms and complaints.