Related Experiment Videos
Assessing the value of pediatrics journals
J L Cho1, J M Belmont, C T Cho
1University of California-San Francisco, School of Medicine, USA. ccho@kumc.edu
Insights
This study analyzes pediatric journal impact to help researchers navigate information overload. Identifying key journals aids efficient discovery of essential clinical and basic science knowledge.
Area of Science:
- Pediatric research
- Bibliometrics
- Scientific communication
Background:
- The vast number of pediatric journals (over 500) presents a challenge for information retrieval.
- Information overload hinders effective extraction of critical clinical and basic science knowledge.
Purpose of the Study:
- To review the impact of 63 pediatric journals and 26 highly cited multidisciplinary journals.
- To guide physicians, scientists, and students in efficiently searching the scientific literature.
Main Methods:
- Citation analysis of pediatric and highly cited journals.
- Evaluation of journal impact based on objective measures.
Main Results:
- A subset of journals contains a significant portion of influential pediatric research.
- Objective measures can help identify key publications within the vast pediatric literature.
Conclusions:
- Strategic literature searching using journal impact analysis can mitigate information overload.
- Efficiently identifying relevant sources is crucial for advancing medical and scientific knowledge.
Abstract:
The pediatric literature comprises more than 500 journals. This paper reviews the relative impact of 63 pediatric journals and 26 highly cited journals that also publish pediatric articles. Using the objective measures of citation analysis and an understanding of the type of literature appropriate for one's purpose of study, physicians, scientists and students can avoid the pitfalls of information overload created by the proliferation of journals and information technology, while effectively extracting the clinical and basic science knowledge that will aid their reading and research. As the medical and scientific knowledge database continues to grow, knowing where to look for significant articles may likely become as important as knowing how to apply the information contained within them. Realizing that a significant portion of influential and important articles can be found in a relatively small group of journals can guide one's initial literature search, but one must also remember that equally valuable information can be found in other publications. Armed with the tools to minimize the field of less appropriate sources, one can more readily achieve the real purpose of a search, which is to uncover the bloom of knowledge and to nurture, cultivate and share it.