Differential MHC expression requirements for positive selection of separate TCR Vb families

Positive selection has been proposed to be involved in protection from diabetes. We examined positive selection by fluorescence-activated cell sorter analyses in thymocytes of protected and susceptible E-transgenic and non-transgenic NOD mice. Three Vb families showed positive selection in E-transgenic mice. Vb6(+)CD4(+) and Vb10(+)CD4(+) thymocytes were found at higher frequencies in both protected NOD-Ea and susceptible NOD-DY mice. The increased frequencies of Vb13(+)CD8(+) thymocytes were found in protected NOD-Ea mice only, and not in susceptible NOD-DY transgenic mice. These three Vb families were further examined in bone-marrow chimeras between NOD-Ea and non-transgenic NOD mice, where we could examine the contribution of E-expressing bone-marrow-derived cells in positive selection. We find that NOD-Ea-->NOD-Ea chimeras have an increased positive selection of Vb13(+)CD8(+) cells and that positive selection is more efficient when both thymic epithelium and bone-marrow-derived cells express the E molecule. This was also seen for Vb6(+)CD4(+) cells. However, for Vb6, bone-marrow-derived cells alone were also capable of positive selection. Positive selection of Vb10(+)CD4(+) cells was restricted to E-expressing thymic epithelium only. For Vb13(+)CD8(+ )cells, we found that positive selection is most efficient with E-expression on both thymic epithelium and bone-marrow-derived cells, although positive selection also occurs with E-positive epithelium only. For Vb6(+) CD4(+) cells, the dominating selecting cells are bone-marrow-derived cells, and Vb10(+)CD4(+ )cells seem to be selected exclusively by the thymic epithelium. Thus, the conditions for positive selection seem to vary considerably between different Vb families.