Nonneoplastic pineal cysts: a clinicopathologic study of twenty-one cases

Twenty-one cases of nonneoplastic pineal cyst are presented. The patients were 13 women and 8 men, with a median age of 33 years. Sixteen patients were symptomatic. Symptomatic cysts had an average size of 16.5 mm. In most cases, symptoms and signs were related to increased intracranial pressure, cerebrospinal fluid obstruction, neuroophthalmologic dysfunction, brainstem and cerebellar compression, and mental status changes. Uncommon clinical presentations in three cases were related to increased cyst size caused by hemorrhage, sudden death, and postural syncope and loss of consciousness. Imaging studies showed a uniform hypodense or hypointense, nonenhancing pineal mass with occasional peripheral calcification and associated with hydrocephalus, aqueductal compression, tectal deformity, and hemorrhage within the cavity, in decreasing order of frequency. Fourteen patients underwent open cyst resection. Histologically, the intact lesions show a unilocular or multilocular cavity, surrounded by a wall comprised of variable amounts of glial tissue, remnants of pineal gland, and an external fibrous capsule. Follow-up information showed 12 patients alive and well without recurrence between 26 and 144 postoperative months. One patient who underwent stereotactic drainage had a recurrence. One symptomatic patient who did not have surgery died suddenly of causes related to the cyst. The present study supports the role of surgical excision for the treatment of symptomatic pineal cysts to obtain adequate tissue for diagnosis and relief of symptoms. The use of histochemical and immunohistochemical studies may prove useful in the distinction of these lesions with astrocytomas and cystic pineal parenchymal tumors.