Randomized in vitro and in vivo evaluation of different biopsy needles and devices for breast biopsy

In an experimental study (in vitro and in vivo) we evaluated the efficacy of various biopsy needles/devices for breast biopsy. In vitro, biopsies of five human cadaveric breast specimens were performed using 33 different needles/devices ranging from 14 to 20-gauge. Of these 33 needles/devices, 22 optimally performing needles were selected for the in vivo study. In the clinical part of the study, 44 breast lesions were randomly biopsied with each of the 22 needles/devices under stereotactic guidance. Tissue specimens were analysed quantitatively and qualitatively. Several automatic long-throw guns (Acecut, Asap, Biopty, Magnum) obtained greater tissue areas and had a better histopathologic score than the conventional type of a side-notch needle like Trucut, an aspiration needle like Surecut, or an end-cut needle like Autovac. The automatic long-throw guns performed better than the short-throw Monopty gun. Regardless of needle size (14-20-gauge), breast biopsies should be routinely performed with automated long-throw side-notch guns (Acecut, Asap, Biopty, Magnum).