Effect of topical tretinoin under occlusion on atypical naevi

Atypical naevi are potential precursors of melanoma and markers of increased melanoma risk. To examine the possibility of chemoprevention of melanoma by retinoids, we studied the effect of topical tretinoin 0.1% (all-transretinoic acid; vitamin A acid) and tretinoin 0.1% with hydrocortisone on atypical naevi. Thirty patients with atypical naevi were enrolled in a prospective randomized double blind study. For each patient three comparable naevi were selected and randomized to receive tretinoin 0.1% (T), tretinoin 0.1% with hydrocortisone 1% (C) or a placebo cream (P) once a week under Actiderm occlusion for 4 months. Baseline views of the naevi, taken with a videomicroscope (magnification 20 x), were assessed for morphological changes compared with views taken 2 months after the beginning of treatment, 1 week after completion of treatment and 6 months later. After completion of the study all naevi in the T and C groups and six naevi in the P group were removed and evaluated histologically for the presence of atypia. The number of naevi that had changed in colour or size was significantly higher in the T and C groups compared with the placebo group. A size reduction took place in 42.9% (T) and 40.0% (C) of the naevi and the colour changed in 75.0% (T) and 66.7% (C). The effect of treatment, in general subtle, did not differ significantly between groups T and C, but naevi treated with C became significantly less irritated. Histologically, 75.0% of the naevi treated with T and 69.6% of the naevi treated with C were atypical. Therefore, no major change was seen in the clinical aspect of atypical naevi after treatment with tretinoin 0.1% or tretinoin with hydrocortisone 1%, and most of the treated naevi still met the histological criteria for atypia after the treatment period. The current management of follow-up of atypical naevi and excision when change to melanoma is suspected is therefore still recommended. Nevertheless, some response was seen, which may justify a further exploration of tretinoin and hydrocortisone 1% therapy for a longer treatment period in combination with research to clarify its mechanism.