受け入れられた手稿の二次審査で特定された問題
J M Garfunkel1, M H Ulshen, H J Hamrick
1Department of Pediatrics, University of North Carolina School of Medicine, Chapel Hill 27599-7230.
JAMA
|March 9, 1990
まとめ
承認された原稿のピアレビューでは欠陥が明らかになったが,それでもほとんどの原稿は出版を推奨された. この研究は,科学出版における原稿レビュープロセスの信頼性に疑問を投げかけています.
科学分野:
- ビビロメトリクス (Bibliometrics) とは
- 学術コミュニケーション
- ピアレビューはピアレビューです.
背景:
- 原稿の承認は,厳格なピアレビューに依存しています.
- このプロセスの信頼性は,科学的完全性にとって極めて重要です.
研究 の 目的:
- ピアレビュープロセスの一貫性と有効性を評価する.
- 認められた手稿に,未発見の重大な欠陥があるかどうかを判断する.
主な方法:
- 受け入れられた原稿は,無知な新しい審査員によって再審査された.
- アシスタントエディターは,レビュー者の批判の重要性を評価した.
主要な成果:
- ほとんどの原稿は批判を受け,さらなる改訂が必要となった.
- 査読者は,原稿の異なった欠陥を特定しました.
- 特定された欠陥にもかかわらず,80%が出版を推奨されました.
結論:
- ピアレビュープロセスは,すべての重要な原稿の欠陥を一貫して特定することができない場合があります.
- 受け入れられた手稿にはしばしば欠陥があるが,通常は拒絶に至らない.
- ピアレビュー基準のさらなる精錬が提案されています.
関連する概念動画
Secondary Active Transport
One example of how cells use the energy contained in electrochemical gradients is demonstrated by glucose transport into cells. The ion vital to this process is sodium (Na+), which is typically present in higher concentrations extracellularly than in the cytosol. Such a concentration difference is due, in part, to the action of an enzyme “pump” embedded in the cellular membrane that actively expels Na+ from a cell. Importantly, as this pump contributes to the high concentration of...
Feedback Inhibition
Biochemical reactions are occurring constantly in cells, converting starting substances to different products, usually with the help of enzymes that speed the reactions. Without enzymes, it would take far too long for most reactions to occur to be useful to the cell!
Meiosis II
Meiosis II is the second and final stage of meiosis. It relies on the haploid cells produced during meiosis I, each of which contain only 23 chromosomes—one from each homologous initial pair. Importantly, each chromosome in these cells is composed of two joined copies, and when these cells enter meiosis II, the goal is to separate such sister chromatids using the same microtubule-based network employed in other division processes. The result of meiosis II is two haploid cells, each containing...
Proofreading
Synthesis of new DNA molecules starts when DNA polymerase links nucleotides together in a sequence that is complementary to the template DNA strand. DNA polymerase has a higher affinity for the correct base to ensure fidelity in DNA replication. The DNA polymerase furthermore proofreads during replication, using an exonuclease domain that cuts off incorrect nucleotides from the nascent DNA strand.Errors during Replication Are Corrected by the DNA Polymerase EnzymeGenomic DNA is synthesized in...
Mismatch Repair
Overview
Feedback Loops
In most cases, excessive hormone production is prevented by negative feedback—a loop that starts with a stimulus inducing the release of a particular substance, like a hormone, to maintain a certain level before triggering a signal that results in a decrease in further release of the hormone.
