编辑同行评审的影响:一个系统的审查
Tom Jefferson1, Philip Alderson, Elizabeth Wager
1Health Reviews Ltd., Rome, Italy. toj1@aol.com
JAMA
|June 1, 2002
概括
编辑上的同行评审被广泛使用,但缺乏对其有效性的强有力的证据. 研究表明,它对质量,可读性和偏差的影响有不同的结果,这表明它的影响仍然不确定.
科学领域:
- 生物医学出版物 生物医学出版物
- 科学传播是科学传播.
背景情况:
- 编辑同行评审是期刊出版物的标准做法.
- 它的假定好处是提高已发表的研究的有用性.
研究的目的:
- 综合关于生物医学期刊编辑同行评审影响的证据.
- 评估各种同行评审阶段和方法的影响.
主要方法:
- 对数据库进行了全面的搜索,并联系了专业组织.
- 确定并审查了19项比较研究,试图控制混因素.
- 由于研究设计和结果的异质性,没有将结果合并.
主要成果:
- 关于盲目评审者/作者的证据是不确定的,一些研究表明积极的影响,但面临着方法学上的局限性.
- 检查清单在改善报告质量方面显示出不同的结果.
- 培训裁判员没有持续提高绩效,沟通方法对质量没有明显的影响.
- 一些研究表明,同行评审可以提高可读性和报告质量,但概括性有限.
结论:
- 编辑的同行评审是一个广泛采用的,但在很大程度上未经测试的过程.
- 编辑对科学出版物的同行评审的实际影响是不确定的.
相关概念视频
The Scientific Method
The scientific method is a detailed, empirical problem-solving process used by biologists and other scientists. This iterative approach involves formulating a question based on observation, developing a testable potential explanation for the observation (called a hypothesis), making and testing predictions based on the hypothesis, and using the findings to create new hypotheses and predictions.Generally, predictions are tested using carefully-designed experiments. Based on the outcome of these...
Feedback Inhibition
Biochemical reactions are occurring constantly in cells, converting starting substances to different products, usually with the help of enzymes that speed the reactions. Without enzymes, it would take far too long for most reactions to occur to be useful to the cell!
Proofreading
Synthesis of new DNA molecules starts when DNA polymerase links nucleotides together in a sequence that is complementary to the template DNA strand. DNA polymerase has a higher affinity for the correct base to ensure fidelity in DNA replication. The DNA polymerase furthermore proofreads during replication, using an exonuclease domain that cuts off incorrect nucleotides from the nascent DNA strand.Errors during Replication Are Corrected by the DNA Polymerase EnzymeGenomic DNA is synthesized in...
Types of Selection
Natural selection influences the frequencies of particular alleles and phenotypes within populations in several different ways. Primarily, natural selection can be directional, stabilizing, or disruptive. Directional selection favors one extreme trait and shifts the population towards that phenotype while selecting against individuals displaying alternate traits. Stabilizing selection favors an intermediate trait with a narrow range of variation. Deviation from the optimal phenotype towards an...
Bias
Bias refers to any tendency that prevents a question from being considered unprejudiced. In research, bias occurs when one outcome or answer is selected or encouraged over others in sampling or testing. Bias can occur during any research phase, including study design, data collection, analysis, and publication.
In statistics, a sampling bias is created when a sample is collected from a population, and some members of the population are not as likely to be chosen as others (remember, each member...
In statistics, a sampling bias is created when a sample is collected from a population, and some members of the population are not as likely to be chosen as others (remember, each member...
Systematic Error: Methodological and Sampling Errors
In the case of systematic errors, the sources can be identified, and the errors can be subsequently minimized by addressing these sources. According to the source, systematic errors can be divided into sampling, instrumental, methodological, and personal errors.
Sampling errors originate from improper sampling methods or the wrong sample population. These errors can be minimized by refining the sampling strategy. Defective instruments or faulty calibrations are the sources of instrumental...
Sampling errors originate from improper sampling methods or the wrong sample population. These errors can be minimized by refining the sampling strategy. Defective instruments or faulty calibrations are the sources of instrumental...

