辐射诱导突变的门是什么? 穆勒-埃文斯辩论:癌症风险评估的一个转折点
1Department of Environmental Health Sciences, Morrill I, N344, University of Massachusetts, Amherst, MA, 01003, USA.
Chemico-biological interactions
|June 25, 2023
概括
赫尔曼·穆勒 (Hermann Muller) 在与罗布利·埃文斯 (Robley Evans) 辩论后,改变了他对辐射诱导突变值的科学立场,与线性无值模型保持一致. 这一转变影响了科学共识和政策建议.
科学领域:
- 辐射生物学 辐射生物学
- 遗传学 是一个遗传学.
- 科学的历史科学的历史.
背景情况:
- 罗布利·埃文斯的1949年论文挑战了赫尔曼·穆勒关于辐射诱导突变的观点,提出了一个值剂量反应模型.
- 诺贝尔奖得主穆勒此前提出了一种线性无值 (LNT) 模型,影响了辐射安全标准.
- 辩论的中心是恩斯特·卡斯帕里 (Ernst Caspari) 在罗切斯特大学 (University of Rochester) 进行的研究,穆勒担任顾问.
研究的目的:
- 分析赫尔曼·穆勒关于辐射剂量-反应模型的立场转变背后的历史背景和科学推理.
- 调查埃文斯和穆勒之间的辩论对线性无值 (LNT) 模型的接受的影响.
- 检查穆勒的逆转立场对科学咨询委员会和辐射保护建议的影响.
主要方法:
- 1947年赫尔曼·穆勒和柯特·斯特恩之间的内部科学信件分析.
- 罗布利·埃文斯 (Robley Evans) 和赫尔曼·穆勒 (Hermann Muller) 发表论文的回顾,重点关注围绕他们1949年辩论的时期.
- 卡斯帕里研究的历史检查及其由穆勒和埃文斯的解释.
主要成果:
- 内部信件显示,穆勒最初支持卡斯帕里研究的对照组,与他自己的数据一致,后来拒绝了它.
- 穆勒对卡斯帕里发现的公开反转和对LNT模型的支持恰逢他与埃文斯的辩论.
- 埃文斯使用卡斯帕里数据来支持值模型似乎引发了穆勒的公开反驳和转向LNT.
结论:
- 穆勒的行动表明他科学立场的战略逆转,受到个人和专业纠纷的影响,而不是仅仅是经验证据.
- 卡斯帕里发现的边缘化以及穆勒随后对LNT的倡导,对辐射保护政策产生了重大影响.
- 这一历史分析强调了科学诚信的重要性,以及个人偏见可能影响科学共识和公共卫生建议的可能性.
相关概念视频
Mutagenicity and Carcinogenicity
1.3K
Mutagenicity and carcinogenicity refer to the ability of drugs to cause genetic defects and induce cancer, respectively. The International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) classifies agents into four groups based on their carcinogenic potential. Group 1 agents are known human carcinogens; group 2A agents are probably carcinogenic to humans; group 3 agents lack data to support their role in carcinogenesis; and group 4 includes agents for which data support that they are not likely to be...
1.3K
Mismatch Repair
4.9K
Organisms are capable of detecting and fixing nucleotide mismatches that occur during DNA replication. This sophisticated process requires identifying the new strand and replacing the erroneous bases with correct nucleotides. Mismatch repair is coordinated by many proteins in both prokaryotes and eukaryotes.
The Mutator Protein Family Plays a Key Role in DNA Mismatch Repair
The human genome has more than 3 billion base pairs of DNA per cell. Prior to cell division, that vast amount of genetic...
The Mutator Protein Family Plays a Key Role in DNA Mismatch Repair
The human genome has more than 3 billion base pairs of DNA per cell. Prior to cell division, that vast amount of genetic...
4.9K
Mutations
38.3K
Mutations are changes in the sequence of DNA. These changes can occur spontaneously or they can be induced by exposure to environmental factors. Mutations can be characterized in a number of different ways: whether and how they alter the amino acid sequence of the protein, whether they occur over a small or large area of DNA, and whether they occur in somatic cells or germline cells.
Chromosomal Alterations Are Large-Scale Mutations
While point mutations are changes in a single nucleotide in...
Chromosomal Alterations Are Large-Scale Mutations
While point mutations are changes in a single nucleotide in...
38.3K
Spontaneous and Induced Mutations
45
Spontaneous mutations arise infrequently during DNA replication due to errors in the process. A key factor behind these errors is tautomeric shifts in nitrogenous bases, where bases transition from keto to enol forms or amino to imino forms. This shift can alter base-pairing rules, leading to mutations. Additionally, reactive oxygen species (ROS) arising from aerobic metabolism can damage DNA, resulting in depurination (loss of a purine base) or depyrimidination (loss of a pyrimidine base).
45
Nucleotide Excision Repair
3.6K
DNA Distortion and Damage
Cells are regularly exposed to mutagens—factors in the environment that can damage DNA and generate mutations. UV radiation is one of the most common mutagens and is estimated to introduce a significant number of changes in DNA. These include bends or kinks in the structure, which can block DNA replication or transcription. If these errors are not fixed, the damage can cause mutations, which in turn can result in cancer or disease depending on which sequences are...
Cells are regularly exposed to mutagens—factors in the environment that can damage DNA and generate mutations. UV radiation is one of the most common mutagens and is estimated to introduce a significant number of changes in DNA. These include bends or kinks in the structure, which can block DNA replication or transcription. If these errors are not fixed, the damage can cause mutations, which in turn can result in cancer or disease depending on which sequences are...
3.6K
Mutations in Microorganisms
34
Mutations are heritable changes in an organism’s genome involving alterations in the base sequence of DNA or RNA. These changes can influence cellular processes and phenotypic traits, potentially transforming the unaltered wild type into a mutant form. Such changes, termed forward mutations, are pivotal in shaping the genetic diversity of organisms.RNA viruses exhibit the highest mutation rates due to the absence of robust proofreading mechanisms during genome replication. In contrast,...
34


