SIA不能只是和FLO一起去
1Philosophy Department, 67-69 Oakfield Avenue, G12 8LP, Glasgow, UK. joe.slater@glasgow.ac.uk.
概括
这篇论文批评了反对堕胎的强化障碍论点 (SIA). 显示SIA依赖其他论点,未能证明自己的前提,并使用有缺陷的原则.
科学领域:
- 伦理学 伦理学 伦理学
- 医学哲学 医学哲学
- 生物伦理学生物伦理学
背景情况:
- 由亨德里克斯 (2018年) 提出并由布莱克肖和亨德里克斯 (2021a,2021b) 修正的损害论证认为,堕胎通常是不道德的,不管胎儿的道德地位如何.
- 这个论点最近得到了加强,但它的逻辑连贯性和独立有效性仍然是争论的主题.
研究的目的:
- 批判性地分析和呈现强化损伤论证 (SIA) 的三个重大问题.
- 评估SIA对外部论点的依赖,其超越性警告的有效性,以及其核心原则的稳定性.
主要方法:
- 哲学论证和逻辑分析.
- 审查SIA的前提,警告和基本原则.
- 将SIA与有关堕胎的现有伦理论点进行比较,例如马奎斯的论点.
主要成果:
- 尽管有修改,但SIA似乎依赖于马奎斯的论点来证明其合理性.
- 论点的"超越性警告"要么提出了关于堕胎允许性的问题,要么需要单独的,未确定的理由.
- 支SIA最新版本的原则是有缺陷的,因为它没有考虑价格下调的原因.
结论:
- 强化损伤论,以目前的形式,面临着重大的逻辑和哲学挑战.
- 论点依赖外部推理及其内部不一致性破坏了其声称的独立有效性.
- 需要进一步开发来解决这些问题,如果SIA被认为是反对堕胎的合理论据.
相关概念视频
Membrane Asymmetry Regulating Transporters
4.6K
Enzymes like flippase, floppase, and scramblase transfer phospholipids from one layer to another in the membrane, thereby affecting membrane asymmetry.
Flippase
Eukaryotic flippases are type-IV P-type ATPases or P4-ATPases belonging to P-type ATPase family proteins that are membrane-bound pumps involved in the ATP-mediated transport of ions and molecules across the membrane. Flippases flip specific phospholipids from the outer to the inner leaflet of a membrane. All P4-ATPases have one...
Flippase
Eukaryotic flippases are type-IV P-type ATPases or P4-ATPases belonging to P-type ATPase family proteins that are membrane-bound pumps involved in the ATP-mediated transport of ions and molecules across the membrane. Flippases flip specific phospholipids from the outer to the inner leaflet of a membrane. All P4-ATPases have one...
4.6K
Schemas
11.7K
A schema is a mental construct consisting of a cluster or collection of related concepts (Bartlett, 1932). There are many different types of schemata, and they all have one thing in common: schemata are a method of organizing information that allows the brain to work more efficiently. When a schema is activated, the brain makes immediate assumptions about the person or object being observed.
11.7K
Laminar Flow: Problem Solving
219
Laminar flow occurs when a fluid moves smoothly in parallel layers with minimal mixing and turbulence. In fluid mechanics, ensuring laminar flow within a pipe is essential for precise control of flow characteristics, especially in engineering applications. The key factor in determining whether flow remains laminar is the Reynolds number, a dimensionless quantity that depends on the fluid's velocity, density, viscosity, and the pipe's diameter. A Reynolds number of 2100 or lower...
219
Uniform Depth Channel Flow: Problem Solving
90
To calculate the flow rate for a trapezoidal channel, first, identify the bottom width, side slope, and flow depth of the channel. The cross-sectional area (A) corresponding to the depth of flow (y), channel bottom width (B), and side slope (θ) is determined by:Next, calculate the wetted perimeter, which includes the bottom width and the sloped side lengths in contact with the water. Using the values of the cross-sectional area and the wetted perimeter, determine the hydraulic radius by...
90
Energy Considerations in Open Channel Flow
119
Open channel flow, where a fluid flows with a free surface exposed to the atmosphere, is primarily governed by gravitational and surface effects, distinguishing it from closed conduit or pipe flow. In open channels such as rivers, canals, and artificial channels, energy analysis provides valuable insights into flow behavior and the relationship between depth, velocity, and slope.Specific Energy and Flow DepthIn open channel flow, the specific energy, E, combines the gravitational potential...
119
Design Example: Forces in Sluice Gate
849
In hydraulic engineering, sluice gates are essential for managing water flow through channels, reservoirs, and irrigation systems. Sluice gates, acting as vertical barriers, regulate water by adjusting the gate's opening height, which changes the velocity and pressure of water flowing beneath the gate. Understanding the forces involved is crucial to designing sluice gates that can withstand dynamic pressure differences, especially when the gate is closed or partially open.
Key variables in...
Key variables in...
849


