"你的指控者是我,还是软件?" 关于概率性DNA分析的模糊性和有争议的专业知识
Hannah Pullen-Blasnik1, Gil Eyal1, Amy Weissenbach1
1Department of Sociology, Columbia University, New York, NY, USA.
Social studies of science
|August 3, 2023
概括
将算法引入专家工作中会产生实际问题. 这项研究表明,Probabilistic DNA Profiling (PDP) 软件破坏了法医分析师的权威,导致法律系统对专业知识和技术的解释发生冲突.
科学领域:
- 法医科学 法医科学 法医科学
- 科学和技术的社会学.
- 法律研究 法律研究
背景情况:
- 专家组越来越多地将算法工具集成到他们的工作流中.
- 新技术的引入可能会挑战现有的专业权威和实践.
- 法医科学在一个对技术进步及其解释敏感的法律体系中运作.
研究的目的:
- 研究将算法工具引入专家工作中的实际挑战和后果.
- 分析法医分析师如何在先进软件的存在下谈判他们的权威和专业知识.
- 了解技术对法医专业知识在法律环境中的解释和部署的影响.
主要方法:
- 在法医实验室引入概率DNA分析 (PDP) 软件的定性研究.
- 分析专家采访和法庭受理听证会数据.
- 检查分析师如何构建算法的代理和意义的帐户.
主要成果:
- 该PDP软件破坏了法医分析师的权威.
- 分析师提出了相互矛盾的说法,将算法描述为一种简单的工具或不可或缺的统计支持.
- 关于专业知识的位置出现了紧张关系:分析师与软件对比.
- 关于诉讼的"预期文化"影响了专家如何管理他们的权威.
结论:
- 算法工具可以通过在专业知识的来源和解释方面创造模糊性来破坏专家权威.
- 法医分析师的角色和权威被重新谈判,以应对技术整合.
- 该研究揭示了在刑事司法系统中不断发展的专业知识和技术的法律和叙事影响.
相关概念视频
Modern Molecular Taxonomy
52
Advancements in molecular biology have revolutionized the identification and characterization of bacteria, with multiple methods leveraging DNA sequencing for enhanced precision. As sequencing technologies improve and costs decline, these approaches are increasingly used in clinical, environmental, and evolutionary studies.Multilocus Sequence Typing (MLST) examines several housekeeping genes, essential chromosomal genes encoding cellular functions, to distinguish strains. Approximately...
52
Proofreading
6.4K
Synthesis of new DNA molecules is carried out by the enzyme DNA polymerase, which adds nucleotides on the daughter strand complementary to the template DNA strand. DNA polymerase has a higher affinity to add the correct base and ensures fidelity during DNA replication. Furthermore, it exhibits proofreading activity during replication, using an exonuclease domain that cuts off incorrect nucleotides from the nascent DNA strand.
Errors During Replication are Corrected by the DNA Polymerase...
Errors During Replication are Corrected by the DNA Polymerase...
6.4K
DNA as a Genetic Template
22.0K
Two structural features of the DNA molecule provide a basis for the mechanisms of heredity: the four nucleotide bases and its double-stranded nature. The Watson-Crick model of double-helical DNA structure, proposed in 1952, drew heavily upon the X-ray crystallography work of researchers Rosalind Franklin and Maurice Wilkins. Watson, Crick, and Wilkins jointly received the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine for their work in 1962. Franklin was, controversially, excluded from the prize for...
22.0K
The DNA Helix
140.1K
Overview
140.1K
Mismatch Repair
40.3K
Overview
40.3K
Probability Laws
41.0K
Overview
41.0K


