在法医人类学中多伯特的过度引用
Kate M Lesciotto1, Angi M Christensen2
1University of North Texas Health Science Center, Fort Worth, Texas, USA.
Journal of forensic sciences
|October 19, 2023
概括
法医人类学家经常引用道伯特标准,经常误解为严格的规则. 该研究建议重点关注质量保证和健全的科学方法,而不是严格遵守可接受性准则.
科学领域:
- 法医科学 法医科学 法医科学
- 法律研究 法律研究
背景情况:
- 杜伯特诉梅雷尔杜夫制药公司 (1993年) 裁决确立了对专家证据的司法评估的新标准.
- 法医人类学研究经常引用道伯特,尽管很少有对其证据的可接受性挑战.
研究的目的:
- 分析为什么法医人类学文章引用道伯特标准并表达对可接受性的担忧.
- 评估在已发表的研究中对达伯特指南的解释和应用.
主要方法:
- 在法医科学杂志上发表的法医人类学文章的定性主题分析.
- 检查引用的频率和上下文与法律可接受性标准相关.
主要成果:
- 随着时间的推移,法律可接受性标准的引用显著增加 (p < 0.001).
- 作家们经常引用道伯特的话来说明研究的背景或证明研究的必要性.
- 一个常见的误解多伯特作为严格的标准,导致专注于定量方法.
结论:
- 多伯特指南经常被误解为科学家的严格指示,而不是灵活的司法工具.
- 法医人类学家应该优先考虑质量保证和科学合理的方法,而不是"令人满意"的可接受性准则.
- 转向强大的科学实践确保了可靠的结果,无论试验的相关性如何.
关键词:
杜伯特 (Daubert) 是一个多伯特.专家证人证据证据证据证据证据法医人类学 法医人类学法律可接受性标准是法律可接受性的标准.定性数据是指质量数据.质量保证 质量保证 质量保证有关数量数据的定量数据.更多相关视频
09:49Holistic Facial Composite Creation and Subsequent Video Line-up Eyewitness Identification Paradigm
Published on: December 24, 2015
14.2K
11:49Enhanced Genetic Analysis of Single Human Bioparticles Recovered by Simplified Micromanipulation from Forensic ‘Touch DNA’ Evidence
Published on: March 9, 2015
15.8K
相关概念视频
Eyewitness Memory
114
Eyewitness memory refers to the recollection of events by someone who has directly witnessed them, often serving as critical evidence in legal settings. This type of memory is commonly used in criminal cases where a witness describes details like a suspect's appearance, clothing, or behavior during a crime. However, despite its perceived reliability, eyewitness memory is prone to significant errors.
One such error is memory distortion, which occurs because human memory does not function...
One such error is memory distortion, which occurs because human memory does not function...
114
In-situ Hybridization
9.4K
In situ hybridization (ISH) is a technique used to detect and localize specific DNA or RNA molecules in cells, tissue, or tissue sections using a labeled probe. The technique was first used in 1969 for the investigation of nucleic acids. It is currently an essential tool in scientific research and clinical settings, especially for diagnostic purposes.
Types of probes and labels
A probe is a complementary strand of DNA or RNA that binds to corresponding nucleotide sequences in a cell. Many...
Types of probes and labels
A probe is a complementary strand of DNA or RNA that binds to corresponding nucleotide sequences in a cell. Many...
9.4K
Bones of the Lower Limb: Femur and Patella
2.5K
The femur is the body's longest and strongest bone spanning the thigh region. Its head articulates with the acetabulum of the hip bone to form the hip joint. A minor indentation on the medial side of the femoral head, called the fovea capitis, serves as the site of attachment for the ligament of the head of the femur. This weak ligament spans the femur and acetabulum and supports the hip joint. The narrowed region below the head is the neck of the femur. The inclination angle between the...
2.5K
Bones of the Lower Limb: Tibia and Fibula
3.5K
The tibia is the main weight-bearing bone of the lower leg. It is larger than the fibula with which it is paired. The tibia is also the second longest bone in the body and is located right below the skin. The proximal end of the tibia forms the medial and the lateral condyle, which articulates with the condyles of the femur to form the knee joint. Between the articulating surfaces is the irregular elevated area known as the intercondylar eminence that serves as the inferior attachment point for...
3.5K
Gross Anatomy of Bone
5.3K
The two main features of a long bone are the diaphysis and the epiphysis.
The diaphysis is the tubular shaft that runs between the proximal and distal ends of the bone. The walls of the diaphysis are composed of dense and hard compact bone made of numerous osteons — the functional unit of the compact bone. The hollow region in the diaphysis is called the medullary cavity, which harbors the bone marrow. In infants and children, this marrow cavity is filled with red marrow, whereas in...
The diaphysis is the tubular shaft that runs between the proximal and distal ends of the bone. The walls of the diaphysis are composed of dense and hard compact bone made of numerous osteons — the functional unit of the compact bone. The hollow region in the diaphysis is called the medullary cavity, which harbors the bone marrow. In infants and children, this marrow cavity is filled with red marrow, whereas in...
5.3K
Bones of the Upper Limb: Humerus
3.3K
The upper limb consists of the arm, forearm, wrist, and hand bones. The humerus is the single bone of the upper arm region. Proximally, it has a large, spherical, smooth head that articulates with the glenoid cavity of the scapula to form the glenohumeral or shoulder joint. The margin of the head is the anatomical neck, a residual epiphyseal plate. Laterally it extends to form bony projections called the greater tubercle and the lesser tubercle. Next to the tubercles is the surgical neck, a...
3.3K
