误解实用主义:对格林哈尔和恩格布雷森的回应
Robert Dingwall1, Jackie Cassell2, Colin J Axon3
1Dingwall Enterprises Ltd and School of Social Sciences, Nottingham Trent University, Nottingham, NG1 4FQ, UK.
Social science & medicine (1982)
|April 27, 2024
概括
这项研究批评了放弃以科学为驱动的政策制定的建议,认为实用主义,与声称相反,强烈支持科学方法和证据. 它得出结论,实用主义提供了宝贵的警,防止流行病驱动的恐惧和过度反应.
科学领域:
- 科学哲学的科学哲学
- 公共卫生政策 公共卫生政策
- 决策 决策 决策 决策
背景情况:
- COVID-19大流行引发了关于科学驱动决策的辩论.
- 最近的一篇文章提议放弃以科学为驱动的政策,转而采取"务实主义的转折".
研究的目的:
- 在科学政策讨论中批判性地分析实用主义的描绘.
- 证明将实用主义描述为反科学的历史不准确性.
- 突出实用主义对科学方法和证据的强调.
主要方法:
- 对现有的文学和哲学论证进行批判性分析.
- 对实用主义的核心原则进行历史检查.
- "科学驱动"与"实用主义"方法的比较分析.
主要成果:
- 将实用主义描述为忽视科学方法的描述在历史上是不准确的.
- 实用主义固有价值严格的科学调查和证据.
- 拟议的"实用主义转折"歪曲了实用主义对科学标准的承诺.
结论:
- 实用主义不是对科学的拒绝,而是坚定的框架,维护科学标准.
- 实用主义对证据和谨慎的强调对于应对公共卫生危机至关重要.
- 放弃以科学为导向的政策,转而支持误解的实用主义,可能会导致在流行病期间做出错误的决策.
相关概念视频
The Representativeness Heuristic
The representative heuristic describes a biased way of thinking, in which you unintentionally stereotype someone or something. For example, you may assume that your professors spend their free time reading books and engaging in intellectual conversation, because the idea of them spending their time playing volleyball or visiting an amusement park does not fit in with your stereotypes of professors.
Confirmation Biases
The confirmation bias is the tendency to focus on information that confirms our existing beliefs and ignore information that is inconsistent with our expectations. For example, if you think that your professor is not very nice, you notice all of the instances of rude behavior exhibited by the professor while ignoring the countless pleasant interactions he is involved in on a daily basis. Have you ever fallen prey to the confirmation bias, either as the source or target of such bias?
Humanistic Psychology
Humanistic psychology emerged in the mid-20th century as a response to the deterministic and pessimistic nature of behaviorism and psychoanalysis. While behaviorism focused on observable behaviors influenced by the environment and psychoanalysis delved into unconscious motivations, both theories suggested that human actions lacked free will. In contrast, humanistic psychology offers a perspective that emphasizes the innate potential for goodness and growth within every individual.
This approach...
This approach...
Cognitivism
Cognitive psychology emerged as a significant field in the mid-20th century. It focused on understanding humans' internal mental processes. This approach emphasizes how people perceive, remember, think, and solve problems—elements critical to human cognition.
Previously dominated by behaviorism, which prioritized observable behaviors and largely ignored mental processes, psychology transformed in the 1950s. Cognitive psychologists argue that understanding how we think and process information is...
Previously dominated by behaviorism, which prioritized observable behaviors and largely ignored mental processes, psychology transformed in the 1950s. Cognitive psychologists argue that understanding how we think and process information is...
Criticisms of the Evolutionary Perspective
In a study where individuals posing as strangers offered compliments and proposed casual sex to students, the responses differed significantly based on gender. Not a single woman accepted the proposal, while 70% of the men agreed. This outcome provides a useful scenario to explore through the lens of evolutionary psychology and social learning theory, highlighting the diverse perspectives on human sexual behaviors.
Evolutionary psychology provides one explanation for these findings, suggesting...
Evolutionary psychology provides one explanation for these findings, suggesting...
Strategies of Self-Presentation I: Strategic Self-Presentation
Strategic self-presentation refers to individuals' intentional efforts to influence how others perceive them. This process is employed in various social and professional settings, such as job interviews, dating, politics, and legal contexts, where individuals seek to shape impressions to gain social or material advantages. While people generally present themselves in ways that align with their authentic characteristics, external factors, such as cognitive load, can hinder their ability to...


