强迫朋友:为什么自由能源原则不是新的汉密尔顿原则
Bartosz Michał Radomski1, Krzysztof Dołęga2
1Institute for Philosophy II, Ruhr-Universität Bochum, D-44780 Bochum, Germany.
Entropy (Basel, Switzerland)
|September 27, 2024
概括
自由能量原理与统计力学中的汉密尔顿静止作用原理相似,但不等价. 这种澄清解决了科学文献中关于它们关系的模糊性.
科学领域:
- 统计力学 统计力学
- 理论物理 理论物理
- 计算神经科学是一种神经科学.
背景情况:
- 自由能量原理与汉密尔顿静止作用原理之间的关系在科学文献中经常被宣称,但定义不佳.
- 现有的文献提出了相互矛盾的观点,表明自由能源原理是类似的,类似的,相当的,或汉密尔顿原理的版本.
研究的目的:
- 严格调查和澄清自由能源原则和汉密尔顿原则之间的关系的确切性质.
- 检查声称关系的两个最合理的解释:一个强烈的 (等效) 和一个弱的 (类比) 解释.
主要方法:
- 强解读的分析:评估将自由能量原理与汉密尔顿原理等同的含义.
- 弱解释的分析:评估两个原则之间的结构相似性和类比.
- 在统计力学框架内,逻辑推理和理论比较原则.
主要成果:
- 这种强烈的解释给自由能源原则的支持者带来了一个不可抗拒的困境,这表明等价性不是一个有效的要求.
- 弱解释,假定基于形式结构相似之处的类比,被支持为关系的更准确描述.
结论:
- 自由能量原理和汉密尔顿的静止作用原理最好被理解为类似而不是等同的.
- 这一结论消除了模两可,并为理解自由能量原理与已确定的物理原理相关的理论基础提供了更清晰的理论基础.
更多相关视频
相关概念视频
Gibbs Free Energy
32.8K
One of the challenges of using the second law of thermodynamics to determine if a process is spontaneous is that it requires measurements of the entropy change for the system and the entropy change for the surroundings. An alternative approach involving a new thermodynamic property defined in terms of system properties only was introduced in the late nineteenth century by American mathematician Josiah Willard Gibbs. This new property is called the Gibbs free energy (G) (or simply the free...
32.8K
An Introduction to Free Energy
8.3K
How can we compare the energy that releases from one reaction to that of another reaction? We use a measurement of free energy to quantitate these energy transfers. Scientists call this free energy Gibbs free energy (abbreviated with the letter G) after Josiah Willard Gibbs, the scientist who developed the measurement. According to the second law of thermodynamics, all energy transfers involve losing some energy in an unusable form such as heat, resulting in entropy. Gibbs free energy...
8.3K
Gibbs Free Energy and Thermodynamic Favorability
6.7K
The spontaneity of a process depends upon the temperature of the system. Phase transitions, for example, will proceed spontaneously in one direction or the other depending upon the temperature of the substance in question. Likewise, some chemical reactions can also exhibit temperature-dependent spontaneities. To illustrate this concept, the equation relating free energy change to the enthalpy and entropy changes for the process is considered:
6.7K
Maxwell's Thermodynamic Relations
2.6K
Maxwell's thermodynamic relations are very useful in solving problems in thermodynamics. Each of Maxwell's relations relates a partial differential between quantities that can be hard to measure experimentally to a partial differential between quantities that can be easily measured. These relations are a set of equations derivable from the symmetry of the second derivatives and the thermodynamic potentials.
All thermodynamic potentials are exact differentials. Therefore, their second-order...
All thermodynamic potentials are exact differentials. Therefore, their second-order...
2.6K
Free Energy and Equilibrium
6.1K
The free energy change for a process may be viewed as a measure of its driving force. A negative value for ΔG represents a driving force for the process in the forward direction, while a positive value represents a driving force for the process in the reverse direction. When ΔG is zero, the forward and reverse driving forces are equal, and the process occurs in both directions at the same rate (the system is at equilibrium).
The reaction quotient, Q, is a convenient measure of the...
The reaction quotient, Q, is a convenient measure of the...
6.1K
Potential-Energy Criterion for Equilibrium
526
Potential energy or potential function plays an essential role in determining the stability of a mechanical system. If a system is subjected to both gravitational and elastic forces, the potential function of the system can be expressed as the algebraic sum of gravitational and elastic potential energy. If the system is in equilibrium and is displaced by a small amount, then the work done on the system equals the negative of the change in the system's potential energy from the initial to...
526


