刑事审判中的陪审员决策中的法官与人工智能:来自两个预先注册的实验的证据
Eiichiro Watamura1, Yichen Liu1, Tomohiro Ioku2
1Graduate School of Human Sciences, Osaka University, Suita, Osaka, Japan.
PloS one
|January 30, 2025
概括
陪审员在判决决策中不喜欢人类法官或人工智能 (AI). 缓解情况影响了判决,但不是判断的来源,这表明陪审员可能会在法律背景下平等地看待人工智能和人类的意见.
科学领域:
- 法律心理学 法律心理学
- 人与计算机的交互
- 人工智能伦理学 人工智能伦理学
背景情况:
- 人工智能 (AI) 预计将影响与公民陪审员的刑事审判.
- 以前的研究表明,人们不愿意在道德决策中使用人工智能.
- 有限的研究比较陪审员对人类法官的依赖与法律判决中的AI.
研究的目的:
- 调查陪审员在判决时是否更多地屈从于人类法官或人工智能.
- 在有减轻性情况的情况下,检查这种偏好,在这种情况下,以人为本的推理是有价值的.
主要方法:
- 与日本参与者进行的两项在线实验 (N=3,466人).
- 参与者评估了谋杀案审判的片段,并做出了判决决定.
- 在有减轻情形和没有减轻情形的条件下,分析了判决决定.
主要成果:
- 没有发现对人类法官或人工智能的判断有明显的偏好.
- 减轻性情形增加了缓刑,不管判决来源如何.
- 参与者对人工智能判断的处理方式与人类法官意见相比较.
结论:
- 陪审员在法律决策中并不是本质上避免算法判断.
- 在某些审判背景下,人工智能意见可能与人类法官相提并论.
- 需要进一步研究人工智能对陪审员决策质量的影响,考虑客观性和情感因素.
相关概念视频
Decision Making: Traditional Method
4.0K
The process of hypothesis testing based on the traditional method includes calculating the critical value, testing the value of the test statistic using the sample data, and interpreting these values.
First, a specific claim about the population parameter is decided based on the research question and is stated in a simple form. Further, an opposing statement to this claim is also stated. These statements can act as null and alternative hypotheses, out of which a null hypothesis would be a...
First, a specific claim about the population parameter is decided based on the research question and is stated in a simple form. Further, an opposing statement to this claim is also stated. These statements can act as null and alternative hypotheses, out of which a null hypothesis would be a...
4.0K
Trial and Error and Algorithm
84
A problem-solving strategy is a plan of action used to find a solution. Different strategies have distinct action plans. Trial and error involves trying different solutions until one works. For instance, to fix a broken printer, you might check ink levels, ensure the paper tray isn't jammed, and verify the printer's connection to your laptop. This method can be time-consuming but is commonly used. Thomas Edison, for example, used trial and error to find a suitable filament for the light...
84
Reason and Intuition
6.3K
The human brain processes information for decision-making using one of two routes: an intuitive system and a rational system (Epstein, 1994; popularized by Kahneman, 2011 as System 1 and System 2, respectively). The intuitive system is quick, impulsive, and operates with minimal effort, relying on emotions or habits to provide cues for what to do next, while the rational system is logical, analytical, deliberate, and methodical. Research in neuropsychology suggests that the...
6.3K
Introduction to Cognitive Psychology
409
Cognitive psychology is the field of psychology dedicated to examining how people think. It attempts to explain how and why we think the way we do by studying the interactions among human thinking, emotion, creativity, language, and problem-solving, as well as other cognitive processes. Cognitive psychology studies how information is processed and manipulated in remembering, thinking, and knowing.
This field emerged in the mid-20th century, following a period dominated by behaviorism, which...
This field emerged in the mid-20th century, following a period dominated by behaviorism, which...
409
Cause and Effect
10.9K
While variables are sometimes correlated because one does cause the other, it could also be that some other factor, a confounding variable, is actually causing the systematic movement in our variables of interest. For instance, as sales in ice cream increase, so does the overall rate of crime. Is it possible that indulging in your favorite flavor of ice cream could send you on a crime spree? Or, after committing crime do you think you might decide to treat yourself to a cone?
10.9K
Eyewitness Memory
85
Eyewitness memory refers to the recollection of events by someone who has directly witnessed them, often serving as critical evidence in legal settings. This type of memory is commonly used in criminal cases where a witness describes details like a suspect's appearance, clothing, or behavior during a crime. However, despite its perceived reliability, eyewitness memory is prone to significant errors.
One such error is memory distortion, which occurs because human memory does not function...
One such error is memory distortion, which occurs because human memory does not function...
85


