同行评审者是否受到他们的工作被引用的影响?
1School of Public Health and Social Work, Queensland University of Technology, Brisbane, Australia.
eLife
|December 23, 2025
概括
评论员在后来的手稿版本中引用他们自己的作品,得到了有利的推. 然而,要求引用的审稿人不太可能批准手稿,这可能会损害客观的同行评审.
科学领域:
- 图书统计学 图书统计学
- 学术传播学术交流
- 研究诚信研究诚信
背景情况:
- 同行评审对于科学质量保证至关重要.
- 对于评论员引用的做法存在担忧,包括潜在的胁迫.
- 开放的同行评审系统为评审者行为提供了透明度.
研究的目的:
- 研究评审者自我引用对同行评审结果的影响.
- 为了区分早期的引用与后来的手稿版本的引用的影响.
- 评估审查员引用请求是否会影响推可能性.
主要方法:
- 采用了一种匹配的观察研究设计.
- 分析包括来自四个公开同行评审期刊的37,000多份同行评审.
- 统计分析检查了评论员引用和推优惠度之间的关系.
主要成果:
- 在第一版后引用的评论员更有可能获得有利的建议 (OR=1.61).
- 要求自我引用的评论员不太可能建议批准 (OR=0.15).
- 评论员更有可能批准引用他们的作品的手稿 (OR=3.5).
结论:
- 评论员的建议可能会受到自我引用或引用请求的影响.
- 这表明,同行评审有时可能变得是交易性的,而不是纯粹的客观.
- 确保客观批评需要解决评论员引用实践中的潜在偏见.
更多相关视频
07:50Global and Current Research Trends of Single-Cell Sequencing in Cancer: A Bibliometric and Visualization Study
Published on: April 18, 2025
816
07:50A Metadata Extraction Approach for Clinical Case Reports to Enable Advanced Understanding of Biomedical Concepts
Published on: September 20, 2018
16.4K
相关概念视频
Review and Preview
8.3K
In statistics, several tools are used to interpret the data. Measures of central tendency represent the characteristics of the data, such as mean, median, and mode. Additionally, measures of variance like standard deviation and range are used to find the spread of data from the mean. Relative standing measures the distance between data locations. Commonly used measures of relative standings are percentile, z score, and quartiles.
Percentiles are a type of fractile that partition data into...
Percentiles are a type of fractile that partition data into...
8.3K
Review and Preview
10.8K
Data are individual items of information obtained from a population or sample. Data may be classified as qualitative (categorical), quantitative continuous, or quantitative discrete. Because it is not practical to measure the entire population in a study, researchers use samples to represent the population. A random sample is a representative group from the population chosen by using a method that gives each individual in the population an equal chance of being included in the sample. Random...
10.8K
Effects of feedback
946
Feedback in control systems plays a critical role in shaping various operational parameters, extending beyond simple error reduction to influence stability, bandwidth, gain, impedance, and sensitivity. Understanding these effects requires examining a basic feedback system characterized by defined input, output, error, and feedback signals.
Feedback significantly modifies the gain of a control system. The gain of a system without feedback is altered by a factor of one plus GH, where G represents...
Feedback significantly modifies the gain of a control system. The gain of a system without feedback is altered by a factor of one plus GH, where G represents...
946
Outliers and Influential Points
5.8K
An outlier is an observation of data that does not fit the rest of the data. It is sometimes called an extreme value. When you graph an outlier, it will appear not to fit the pattern of the graph. Some outliers are due to mistakes (for example, writing down 50 instead of 500), while others may indicate that something unusual is happening. Outliers are present far from the least squares line in the vertical direction. They have large "errors," where the "error" or residual is the...
5.8K
Impact Loading
634
Impact loading occurs when a moving object collides with a stationary structure, such as a rod with a uniform cross-sectional area fixed at one end. Under these conditions, the rod absorbs the kinetic energy from the striking object, leading to deformation and subsequent stress development. As the rod returns to its original position and reaches maximum stress, the absorbed energy, initially manifested as kinetic energy, transforms entirely into strain energy.
In cases of elastic deformation,...
In cases of elastic deformation,...
634
Impact
448
Impact occurs when two bodies collide, leading to the application of impulsive forces between them. Analyzing impact mechanics involves considering two colliding particles moving along a line known as the line of impact, which passes through their centers and is perpendicular to the contact plane.
When particles with different initial velocities collide, they induce deformation by applying equal and opposite impulses. At the point of maximum deformation, the particles move together with...
When particles with different initial velocities collide, they induce deformation by applying equal and opposite impulses. At the point of maximum deformation, the particles move together with...
448
