Recruitment and retention of rural physicians: issues for the 1990s

This paper briefly describes a number of structural and economic changes in the profession of medicine and in the rural medical care delivery system that have occurred since about 1970. Changes in the national physician supply; in the training, work, and practice characteristics of physicians; in the demographic characteristics of physicians; in the medical resources available in rural communities; and in federal and state support for the provision of medical services are noted. Four conceptual models that underlie physician recruitment and retention programs for small towns and rural communities are described. These include affinity models, which attempt to recruit rural persons into training or foster interest in rural practice among trainees; economic incentive models, which address reimbursement or payment mechanisms to increase economic rewards for rural practice; practice characteristics models, which address technical, collegial, referral, and other structural barriers to rural practice; and indenture models, which recruit temporary providers in exchange for scholarship support, loan forgiveness, or licensure. Examples of applications of each model are provided and the effects of changes in the medical care system on the effectiveness of each model are assessed. Finally, it is argued that elements of an optimal model for the recruitment of physicians to rural practice include the promotion of medical careers among rural high school students, the provision of financial and cultural support for their training, the development of technical and collegial support systems, and the limited use of indenture mechanisms to meet the needs of the most impoverished or isolated rural settings.