Related Experiment Videos
Metabolic and performance responses to constant-load vs. variable-intensity exercise in trained cyclists.
G S Palmer1, L B Borghouts, T D Noakes
1School of Life Science, Kingston University, Kingston upon Thames, Surrey KT1 2EE, United Kingdom.
Journal of Applied Physiology (Bethesda, Md. : 1985)
|September 14, 1999
Summary
Steady-state (SS) and variable-intensity (VI) cycling show similar whole-body responses but differ in muscle fuel use. VI cycling spares muscle glycogen and increases glucose oxidation, yet time trial performance remains unchanged.
Area of Science:
- Exercise Physiology
- Sports Science
- Metabolic Research
Background:
- Understanding fuel utilization during different exercise intensities is crucial for optimizing athletic performance.
- Constant-load (steady-state, SS) and variable-intensity (VI) exercise protocols elicit distinct metabolic demands.
- The impact of these protocols on muscle glycogen utilization and glucose oxidation requires further investigation.
Purpose of the Study:
- To compare glucose oxidation (Glu(ox)) and glycogen degradation between SS and VI cycling at the same average power output.
- To assess the subsequent 20-km time trial (TT) performance after these exercise protocols.
- To investigate differences in muscle fiber recruitment and substrate utilization.
Main Methods:
- Six trained cyclists completed four trials: two 140-min exercise bouts (SS and VI) with muscle biopsies for glycogen analysis, and two similar trials including a 20-km TT.
- During experimental rides, subjects ingested a [U-(14)C]glucose solution to measure Glu(ox) rates.
- Measurements included O(2) consumption, energy expenditure, heart rate, plasma lactate, and muscle glycogen content (periodic acid-Schiff's staining).
Main Results:
- Whole-body responses (O(2) consumption, energy expenditure, heart rate, perceived exertion) were similar between SS and VI trials.
- Plasma lactate was significantly higher during VI compared to SS.
- VI cycling resulted in less total muscle glycogen utilization (49% vs. 65% for SS) and higher total Glu(ox) (99.2g vs. 83.9g for SS).
- Fewer type I fibers were glycogen-depleted after VI (59%) compared to SS (98%), with greater type II fiber involvement in VI.
- Despite metabolic differences, subsequent TT performance was not significantly different between SS and VI trials.
Conclusions:
- 140 minutes of either SS or VI exercise at the same average intensity elicits similar whole-body metabolic and cardiovascular responses.
- VI exercise promotes greater glucose oxidation and spares muscle glycogen compared to SS exercise.
- Differences in skeletal muscle carbohydrate metabolism and fiber recruitment do not translate to performance disparities in a subsequent time trial.